Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Katie McCormick describes late-night party boat noise

New York City Council · Oct 20, 2026 · starts 3:29:04 · 2 min 46 sec

A City Island resident supports studying ferry service but suggests Orchard Beach; she describes months of 311 complaints about loud music from party boats until 2-4 AM and asks for proactive enforcement.

Virginia Maloney

Next is Katie McCormick, followed by Kiana Diaz.

Member of the Public - Jabril Jallo

You may begin.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

Good afternoon, and thank you for allowing me to speak today.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

My name is Katie McCormick, and I am a City Island resident.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

I support the city's efforts to study ferry service to City Island, but I believe Orchard Beach should seriously be considered as a location for a ferry landing, given its parking, open space, accessibility, and existing waterfront infrastructure.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

But I also want to address another issue that is directly affecting waterfront residents, the ongoing problem of late-night party boat noise.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

The issue of party boats, illegal charters, and nighttime activity on New York City's waterways is not theoretical for those of us who live along the waterfront.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

For years, residents around City Island and the surrounding waterways have been dealing with extremely loud, amplified music coming from boats late at night and at times into the early morning hours.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

personally spent

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

I've personally spent months reporting these incidents.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

I have submitted 311 complaints, provided videos, contacted the NYPD and Harbor Patrol, and communicated repeatedly with elected officials.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

There have been nights when the music continued for hours, despite repeated calls for assistance.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

Behind every one of these complaints are real people who are trying to live their lives.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

We have families, working parents, and small children who need a good night's sleep.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

When loud music continues until 2, 3, or 4 in the morning, it doesn't just disturb us in the moment.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

It affects our children's sleep, our ability to function at work, and our entire family's well-being the following day.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

No family should have to wonder whether we will be able to sleep in their own home because of loud music coming from boats on the water.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

I appreciate the officers and the Harbor Patrol personnel who have responded, and I recognize that they are working within their resources and procedures available to them.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

My concern is the larger system.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

Too often, enforcement feels reactive rather than preventative.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

By the time a resident identifies where the music is coming from, makes a complaint, and waits for someone to respond, the activity may have already been going on for hours.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

And when a complaint is closed, that does not necessarily mean the underlying problem has been resolved.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

What waterfront communities need.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

Sorry, is consistent predictable enforcement present during the hours when these problems actually occur?

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

If the city knows that certain waterways become hotspots on certain nights and during certain hours, resources should be positioned there proactively.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

rather than relying on residents to call after the problem has already begun.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

I would ask the council to go beyond the number of summonses issued or complaints closed and ask more important questions.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

Are waterfront residents actually experiencing a sustained improvement in their quality of life?

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

Thank you very much, Katie.

Member of the Public - Katie McCormick

Thank you.

Virginia Maloney

Thank you for your testimony.