Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Michael Shanley says City Island needs ferry investment

New York City Council · Oct 20, 2026 · starts 3:09:59 · 1 min 55 sec

A 31-year City Island resident says the main street has shuttered shops and little foot traffic; he feels unconnected and says a ferry would help retirees and families visit other boroughs.

Member of the Public - Michael Shanley

Hello, my name is Michael Shanley.

Member of the Public - Michael Shanley

I am a lifelong Bronx resident and have lived on City Island for the past 31 years with my wife and family.

Member of the Public - Michael Shanley

I am in full support of a ferry landing on City Island for many, many reasons.

Member of the Public - Michael Shanley

When I first discovered City Island years ago and considered it as a potential place to buy a home and raise my family, I always said that our beautiful little island had so much potential.

Member of the Public - Michael Shanley

Unfortunately, over the past 31 years, we've never reached it.

Member of the Public - Michael Shanley

City Island Avenue today, unfortunately, and I hate to say, looks like a depressed has-been of a town.

Member of the Public - Michael Shanley

There are so many shuttered shop fronts.

Member of the Public - Michael Shanley

The businesses that are opening are really struggling just to keep their doors open.

Member of the Public - Michael Shanley

There's very little foot traffic.

Member of the Public - Michael Shanley

My wife and I are recent retirees, and our plan is to spend our retired years exploring our beautiful city.

Member of the Public - Michael Shanley

Unfortunately, we feel so unconnected to the rest of New York City.

Member of the Public - Michael Shanley

In fact, City Island is often even left off maps of New York City because we don't have a direct subway line.

Member of the Public - Michael Shanley

We feel like we're the forgotten borough.

Member of the Public - Michael Shanley

We need the investment.

Member of the Public - Michael Shanley

We need access.

Member of the Public - Michael Shanley

My oldest son and his wife live in Astoria.

Member of the Public - Michael Shanley

You know, it's so convenient for us to take the ferry, transfer at 98th Street, and go to Astoria, Queens.

Member of the Public - Michael Shanley

The same, we like to visit other boroughs, Brooklyn and Queens and Staten Island, but it just is so much more complicated not having transportation options.

Member of the Public - Michael Shanley

Thank you.

Virginia Maloney

Thank you.