Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Adler lists solutions: reduce call volume, end fire promotion, EMS department

New York City Council · Oct 20, 2026 · starts 3:58:12 · 2 min 47 sec

Adler says the city must reduce call volume by 10%, reclaim EMS members who went to fire, and reduce CFR use when not necessary. He also calls for ending the fire promotional pathway, public education on 911 overuse, and a serious conversation about an independent EMS department.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

I think there have been solutions introduced.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

The most important ones I would just like to list off in whatever time I have remaining because they are important and they are not being considered.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

Everyone says, where is this $200 to $400 million to pay Finney EMS going to come from?

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

And the answer is we need to reduce call volume in this city by 10%.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

That is in the citizen budget report.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

We need to use medic and EMT units.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

We need to use firefighter and EMT units, and we need to reclaim the EMS that have gone to fire to be a resource,

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

and we need to reduce CFR utilization except when necessary because it is more expensive to send five people that make $109K than send two people that make $57K.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

This is all the 2018 Citizen Budget Commission, and I believe it should inform us where some of the money could come from and things that could be acceptable to the UFA and 2507.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

Finally, I know I'm over time.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

There is something called the Gilbay Malay proposal.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

They are senior members.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

They are paramedics.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

Their first thing is well known to everybody.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

We want to get Fidney EMS to 109K after five years.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

of service or as close to, that is our conception of parity.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

Two, we need to end the promotional to fire because people should not use our field as a stepping stone and it closes the gap and attracts people from other sectors that want to make a career.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

Third thing, we need to educate the public on 911 overuse, abuse, and misuse because if the public is truly educated about what is 911 calls, we go from 6,000 calls to 3,000 and then it can be handled by the various

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

alignments we have.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

Finally,

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

Brannan introduced the independent department of EMS on behalf and in solidarity with Local 2507 and 3621, not because anybody wants to wrench EMS out of the hands of the fire department,

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

but a serious conversation has to be had about 70 actors that are deploying ambulances, four sectors, 10 unions.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

And if we do not force that conversation through a department of EMS that does not necessarily need to command and control all ambulances, then we are

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

creating piecemeal solutions, which respectfully, Chair Areola, I understand what your local laws do.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

They create accountability.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

They create structure.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

But our men and women are dying.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

Our citizens are dying.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

And it feels often like the city and OLR and the mayor is dancing in a circle around us.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

Sorry to go over.