Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Adler says hospital-based EMS stands with FDNY EMS

New York City Council · Oct 20, 2026 · starts 3:56:29 · 1 min 43 sec

Walter Adler, a hospital-based paramedic and president of the EMS Public Advocacy Council, says it is painful to watch FDNY EMS bleed members. He says hospital-based EMS is not a competing force and that the different pay systems are by design.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

Good afternoon.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

My name is Walter Adler.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

I am a hospital-based paramedic.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

I am the president of the Emergency Medical Services Public Advocacy Council.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

I'm also an 1199 delegate.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

I'm here today as a paramedic who works for the voluntary hospitals to say it is painful and shameful to watch what is happening to the bleeding of FDNY EMS.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

We see how their union leaders are struggling, organizing, negotiating, fighting for 4.6 years is what it now feels like.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

And we give them respect.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

We see their members.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

We do our jobs with their members.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

I'm the ALS.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

I have some Fidney BLS.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

I began my career as a scared little 18-year-old working for TransCare in Canarsie.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

I became a Midwood Teamster.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

I was in 2507 for four years as a fire department EMT.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

And now I'm a proud, proud, proud member of 1199 at a hospital.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

And I will say this, above all else, I am a paramedic and I was an EMT.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

And I want our brothers and sisters in Fidney to know that we're not a competing force.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

We're out here with them.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

We get paid completely different ways in different sectors.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

But that is by design.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

It is not that there's like a villain in this story.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

The council makes resolutions that say parity is important.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

Mayors make promises.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

They do their best.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

The OLR isn't a hateful group of people, so we think.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

Everybody's trying their best to get justice for our municipal EMS workforce.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

And we, the about 3,000 members of the 1199 hospital-based EMS, with our brothers and sisters in Presbyterian, who are non-union, we are saying we are not a competing force and we see you out there.

Member of the Public - Walter Adler

That then said...