Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Ariola questions FDNY on ambulance no-show at St. Francis Prep

New York City Council · Oct 20, 2026 · starts 0:33:52 · 2 min 35 sec

Ariola asks why an ambulance never arrived for Jennifer Daly's son Kevin after he showed signs of a stroke. Esposito calls it unacceptable, and Chief Paul Miano says the 911 system was experiencing more than 100 extra calls; the call was classified as unknown and an ambulance arrived after the patient had already left for the hospital.

Joann Ariola

Thank you, Chief.

Joann Ariola

I just want to go and ask a few questions regarding the incident that took place at St.

Joann Ariola

Francis Preparatory High School that Ms.

Joann Ariola

Daly testified to.

Joann Ariola

Going back to her testimony, Jennifer Daly noted that an ambulance never arrived for her child.

Joann Ariola

Who was showing signs of a stroke.

Joann Ariola

Can you explain why an ambulance did not arrive that day?

John Esposito

So before I defer to Chief Miano, we want to express our thoughts that it is unacceptable that we're not able to get an ambulance there in time.

John Esposito

As a parent, the thought that your child goes to school, has a medical emergency, it's recognized and they call for help.

John Esposito

It's unacceptable and we have to do better.

John Esposito

I'll pass it to Chief Miano and Chief Werner to describe the specific circumstances and what happened that day.

Joann Ariola

Thank you.

Paul Miano

So echoing what Chief Esposito just said, this is a tragic incident that we, you know, want to try and stop from happening in the future.

Paul Miano

During the period of time where this call came in, EMD or the 911 system was experiencing an extreme number of calls, more than 100 calls than we normally receive during this period of time.

Paul Miano

Our call takers.

Paul Miano

They don't just answer a phone and say, where's the address, and then dispatch out an ambulance.

Paul Miano

They spend a few minutes on the phone with each caller trying to ascertain exactly what is going on with that caller so we can dispatch the correct type of ambulance.

Paul Miano

Unfortunately, during this time when the call was received, again, there were a high number of calls that came in, and our alarm receiving dispatches were on the phone with other callers.

Paul Miano

That does not mean that this call was not dispatched.

Paul Miano

It was dispatched.

Paul Miano

It was sent from our NYPD dispatcher over to the EMS dispatch, and it was put into the system.

Paul Miano

It was classified as an unknown condition because we did not get to speak to the caller and triage the call ourself.

Paul Miano

The call was dispatched out to an ambulance.

Paul Miano

The ambulance did start traveling towards the call, but the ambulance was coming from a distance, and it did take beyond.

Paul Miano

The ambulance did arrive.

Paul Miano

They arrived, unfortunately, after the patient left to go to the hospital.

Joann Ariola

At this point, I'm just going to pause questions because we've been joined by our speaker, Julie Menon, and she does have a statement that she would like to read.