Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Narcisse asks about AMA rates, common ER visits, and mental health

New York City Council · Oct 20, 2026 · starts 1:17:07 · 2 min 53 sec

Narcisse asks about patients leaving against medical advice and the most common reasons for emergency visits. Motzquist says left-without-being-seen data is around 2%, common complaints include chest pain, belly pain, and shortness of breath, and mental health calls are complex with B-HEARD and 988 partnerships.

Mercedes Narcisse

And that's why sometimes they sign against the medical advice and walk out.

Mercedes Narcisse

How many, by example, how many of our patients actually get in the emergency room and did not finish getting care and sign against medical advice?

Mercedes Narcisse

Do you have that data?

Josh Motzquist

I don't have the AMA data with us, and I'm happy to get it for you.

Josh Motzquist

I know that our left without being seen data is around 2% in general.

Mercedes Narcisse

About 2%?

Josh Motzquist

Yes.

Mercedes Narcisse

What are the most common reasons people visit emergency rooms?

Mercedes Narcisse

Do you track them to assess the need to continue improving services?

Josh Motzquist

Yes, and every facility is going to have a little differences, right?

Josh Motzquist

A little different nuances to what their patient population comes to.

Josh Motzquist

In general, patients come in for chest pain, come in for belly pain, come in for, you know, shortness of breath.

Josh Motzquist

Under EMTALA, we take care of any patients that come in, right?

Josh Motzquist

And so when an individual layperson might perceive to be an emergency, we're here to help them and figure out whether it is a true life-threatening emergency or not and try to care for them as best of our ability.

Mercedes Narcisse

Because we track it in the year.

Mercedes Narcisse

We ask people what they come after the triage nurse finished.

Mercedes Narcisse

We have a data that we enter it to say why that person is here.

Mercedes Narcisse

So that data should be easy to gain because the nurses have to tell you why from the triage nurse, why that person was here specifically.

Mercedes Narcisse

What was the main complaint?

Josh Motzquist

Yes, and each facility has slightly different chief complaints that are their priority.

Josh Motzquist

I don't have the data in front of me, but we can break it down for you if you'd like us to.

Mercedes Narcisse

What are you assuring New Yorkers with mental health needs are being taken to the correct facilities instead of the emergency room?

Mercedes Narcisse

How can we streamline this process?

Josh Motzquist

That is a complicated question.

Josh Motzquist

I'm not sure I'm prepared to answer today.

Josh Motzquist

Mental health crises are really important.

Josh Motzquist

I know that the 911 system is central to the BHERDS operation that we're working with, and that we are continuing to work closely with both FDNY and NYPD to address any operational challenges for the mental health crisis system,

Josh Motzquist

and improving call triage, working with agency partners to drive mental health calls to 988 as an example.

Josh Motzquist

Other behavioral health services can reduce unnecessary strain on emergency resources to make sure that New Yorkers who are experiencing mental health crises receive the most appropriate response.

Mercedes Narcisse

So you're doing some kind of education too as well for those patients?

Mercedes Narcisse

Let's say a patient come in and they have mental health, like it's not really an emergency acute to be in an emergency room.

Mercedes Narcisse

So do we use that opportunity?

Mercedes Narcisse

I used to tell the patient, these are the information and kind of guide the patient through the next step.

Josh Motzquist

We try to provide patients with the appropriate resources to help them get the care they need.

Mercedes Narcisse

Thank you.

Mercedes Narcisse

No problem.

Mercedes Narcisse

And you talk very kind of a little bit.

Mercedes Narcisse

I apologize for that.

Mercedes Narcisse

I want everybody to be able to hear the answer.