Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Sanchez asks about NYPD medical training and EMS morale

New York City Council · Oct 20, 2026 · starts 1:57:27 · 3 min 43 sec

Sanchez asks about the training NYPD officers have when responding to medical emergencies and how EMS workers feel about police filling in. Esposito says FDNY does not know what training NYPD has, while Miano says NYPD complements EMS and that the agencies train together.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Second question, I probably won't have time for more, but just in terms of the quality of care that happens.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

So if a police officers, we know they have basic emergency medical training, but they're not trained and equipped in the same level as EMTs and paramedics.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Is that correct?

John Esposito

And that is part of the issue, right?

John Esposito

We don't know what training they have or what care is being given.

John Esposito

And I'll pass it to Chief Miano.

Paul Miano

So I do want to say that NYPD does routinely respond to EMS calls.

Paul Miano

And it is sometimes based on...

Paul Miano

Why we're being called, right?

Paul Miano

If there is a fight or if it's due to a motor vehicle accident, right?

Paul Miano

These are things that NYPD has to respond to.

Paul Miano

They don't respond in place of us, but we are one emergency response service, whether it's fire, EMS, NPD, and we respond together.

Paul Miano

And oftentimes NYPD is responding more for us, right?

Paul Miano

To make sure that we're okay, to make sure that our members are safe while operating in an environment.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Thank you, Chief.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

I understand that.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

And thank you, Google, also told me as much.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

But a 90-year-old man, senior, you know, who falls down two steps, hits his head, there is no threat to EMS there.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

And so, you know, as a layperson, I'm understanding that NYPD is responding because they know that EMS will be delayed.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

And so I think there's a very big question there to be answered, please.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

You know, NYPD.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

And yourselves, please follow up with us.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

What is the training that they have?

Pierina Ana Sanchez

And what is the training that they don't?

Pierina Ana Sanchez

And I just want to be respectful of time.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

I can send these in writing and continue the conversations with you all because my questions here are founded in a deep respect, appreciation, and even love for what our EMS are doing on the ground.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

And, you know, I think everybody's repeating that we need to solve this problem.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

But I guess I'll just close with how does this make EMS workers themselves feel?

Pierina Ana Sanchez

How do paramedics feel knowing that NYPD does not have the training that they do, that others do not have the training that they do, but they are nonetheless being dispatched while EMS workers are so undervalued in our city?

John Esposito

I know that our EMTs and paramedics, I believe, are the best trained and best experienced that we have in this country.

John Esposito

They get out there and they do their jobs and they are very, very good at it.

John Esposito

I think that competitive.

John Esposito

That competitive spirit and that can-do spirit that we all have in the fire department is you want to be the one that goes there and does your job.

John Esposito

You don't want anybody else doing your job.

John Esposito

You want to get there and provide that help and save that life.

John Esposito

And that's, I think, what makes our people as good as they are.

Paul Miano

Sorry, I don't believe that we believe that PD is responding in place of us.

Paul Miano

I believe that we all feel that we complement each other, right?

Paul Miano

Where if someone who has basic training, whether it's CFR or NYPD, can start care prior to our arrival, that's just an additional link in the chain of survival that the city is able to provide.

Paul Miano

And that's why we do drills and we do joint training with NYPD, with the fire department, with EMS.

Paul Miano

That's why we work together, because when the city is in crisis, those three agencies, well, two agencies, are the ones that are stepping up.

Paul Miano

And we need to be able to work in harmony with each other and understand everyone's limitations and also what we bring to the table.