Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Chris Chatterjee supports the idling law and says it is working

New York City Council · Oct 20, 2026 · starts 5:27:14 · 2 min 27 sec

Chatterjee, using another participant's Zoom link, says idling harms children and that buses and garbage trucks often run engines unnecessarily. He says the law is working and that delayed fines are a bureaucratic problem, not a reason to change the law.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

Can I go?

James F. Gennaro

Okay.

James F. Gennaro

Great.

James F. Gennaro

Great to have you.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

I can't hear anything.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

I guess I'll just start speaking.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

Sure.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

Thank you for taking the time, Mr.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

Gennaro, if you can hear me.

Member of the Public - Patrick Kane

Yes, I don't know what to say.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

Yeah, no, a lot of the companies, you know, they idle on the roads.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

They really shouldn't be doing it.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

You have no idea how many children walk by and breathe these emissions.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

So I think the law is doing a great job.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

And, you know, a bus company, a bus could just be sitting there waiting for...

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

You know, say a Broadway show to end, they could be there for 30 minutes, people are taking selfies, they're just late to arrive, they're lost.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

Meanwhile, the bus is idling the whole time.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

So, I mean, it's ridiculous to, it's ridiculous what I've seen out looking for these violators.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

Same thing with the garbage truck industry, they go into the

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

They could go into the building.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

They could take the elevator down.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

It could take forever to get the garbage out.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

Meanwhile, the truck's idling the whole time.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

So it's just ridiculous.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

They need to cut the engine.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

It's better for everybody.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

They've started doing so.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

Action Environmental.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

I've noticed has been off lately.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

Academy has been off lately.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

Pandemic, you know, but we still got to get the word out.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

And I know it takes a long time for them to get the fine, but, you know, that's just city bureaucracy, government bureaucracy.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

That's not a law change.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

That's, you know, bureaucratic hurdles.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

I think we're, you know, the law is good as is.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

And, you know, it's working.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

I've seen it work.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

Every year it's getting better and better.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

So it's just amazing to see.

James F. Gennaro

Thank you very much, Mr.

James F. Gennaro

Hartman.

James F. Gennaro

I don't think you can hear me, but, you know, my voice will be on the record, and I'm glad you got an opportunity to testify.

James F. Gennaro

And it was...

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

I'm not Hartman.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

I'm Chatterjee.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

Yeah.

James F. Gennaro

You're who?

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

Chatterjee.

James F. Gennaro

Oh, I'm sorry.

James F. Gennaro

I guess we didn't...

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

Yeah, his hand is also up, but I don't know if he wants to talk.

James F. Gennaro

Oh, okay.

James F. Gennaro

It seems like, yeah, we have many people as Chris Hartman.

James F. Gennaro

But so I don't know what that's about.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

I probably used his link.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

I used his link.

James F. Gennaro

Oh, I used his link.

James F. Gennaro

Okay.

James F. Gennaro

Well, thank you very much for your testimony.

Member of the Public - Chris Hartman

You're welcome.

James F. Gennaro

Okay.

James F. Gennaro

Okay.

James F. Gennaro

Yeah.

James F. Gennaro

Okay.