Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Joseph Ferrara says cement trucking is inundated by citizen idling complaints

New York City Council · Oct 20, 2026 · starts 1:03:08 · 2 min 44 sec

Ferrara describes his family cement-delivery business and says it receives many citizen complaints. He argues the program has become a 'money grab' and suggests complainants should first tell drivers to shut off engines rather than immediately filming them.

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

Good afternoon, Chairman Gennaro.

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

My name is Joseph Ferrara, and I am an owner and president of Aggregate and Cement Trucking.

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

My son and I own and operate this company.

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

Prior to this, my family was in the ready mix concrete business for our brothers building materials from 1969 through 2015.

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

So our business involves delivering cement, which is a raw material as opposed to concrete, to concrete plants and construction sites.

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

So we go to the same locations every day, multiple deliveries, and we are just getting inundated with these idling violations.

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

And my question to the enforcement community and the legislators is,

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

This is, we're in favor of eliminating or minimizing unnecessary idling.

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

We're all for it.

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

I just, I have two grandchildren.

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

I'd love to see them live and healthy long lives.

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

But if the objective of this legislation

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

is to minimize or eliminate unnecessary idling.

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

Most of our violations come from citizen complaints.

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

We don't have an opportunity to cross-examine them, but they take a video, and it's kind of like, gotcha, and it's a money grab.

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

So my suggestion...

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

Is if a citizen is going to take a video, if they want to eliminate unnecessary idling, we have 18 truck drivers.

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

They make dozens of deliveries a day.

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

I've instructed them on the law, and you shouldn't idle if you're not pumping off.

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

But have the citizen tell the driver, hey, do you know you can't do that?

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

And if they say F you and they take a video of it, but if they stop, they've accomplished their purpose.

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

Someone on the prior panel talked about how the drivers shut their trucks off when they see them.

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

But couldn't we make it a requirement if you really want to clean up the air?

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

Instructor drivers.

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

They may not

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

That's the purpose of it.

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

This has become a multi-million dollar money grab.

Member of the Public - Joseph Ferrara

And it's not fair to businesses that pay taxes, employ union members.