Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Justin Bernstein shares homeless perspective and supports the complaint program

New York City Council · Oct 20, 2026 · starts 3:15:05 · 2 min 22 sec

Bernstein says he was homeless in lower Manhattan and saw buses and trucks idling nonstop. He says the program changed driver behavior and urges the Council to reject 561-A.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

All right.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

Yes, sir.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

Good afternoon, everyone.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

I just want to introduce myself.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

My name is Justin Bernstein.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

I'm a participant of the Idling program.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

I was born and raised in Brooklyn.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

As a Brooklyn native, I've always noticed there was a problem with trucks and buses idling, especially in the city.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

I always thought it was just part of life being in the big city.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

My story is probably going to be a little bit different because I was homeless for quite some time in the lower Manhattan area.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

I saw firsthand how there would be buses and trucks of all sizes idling nonstop.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

You could not walk down Canal Street without seeing a fleet of coach-sized buses idling.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

There was really nothing you could do about it before.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

There has always been a law against idling, but it was not enforced.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

This is the first of many examples that made me want to take action when I discovered the idling program.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

Once this program had begun, it did not take long before I noticed change.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

I saw firsthand how this program changed the driving habits of a lot of drivers.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

Companies were being held accountable, and through that accountability, change was being achieved.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

I am proud to say I have helped in this process and the opportunity the city gave every citizen to do what they can do.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

I am honored to work with all the good people involved to make this a positive change in this city.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

I am just one New Yorker, and a lot of people besides myself have put in a ton of work into this project, and it would be soul-crushing for all of our hard work to be possibly tossed out.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

I believe there are tools available to make this program more efficient and easier for all parties involved.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

Just being able to participate in this program helped me tremendously when there was no other opportunities.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

I say no to 561 as we already have a lot of stipulations with refrigeration units, lift gates, buses picking up and dropping off active.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

processing devices and it uses all these excuses as trucks I see use these lift gates they turn them on and off to avoid

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

to reset basically reset the timer reset the clock so you would have to start your three minutes over again all these are already being used to abuse the system

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

I've seen this happen in the field.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

Once drivers are aware, they're able to cheat the system.

Member of the Public - Justin Bernstein

From what I've seen, they will cheat the system.

James F. Gennaro

Thank you very much for your compelling testimony and personal history and life story.

James F. Gennaro

We're grateful to have you here today.