Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Chair Sherman responds on MIH affordability and deeper affordability tools

New York City Council · Oct 21, 2026 · starts 1:43:34 · 1 min 30 sec

He acknowledges tension, says CPC can modify MIH levels, and proactive planning can lay out tools for deeper affordability; East New York example shows mix of MIH and city tools.

Dan Garodnick

Thank you for your question.

Dan Garodnick

And again, thank you for your efforts and planning work that's happening in Bay Ridge.

Dan Garodnick

I recognize that in certain parts of the city, there is that tension based on the AMI and the MIH rent calculations where the affordable rents are very much in line or sometimes a little bit higher than what we're seeing in the existing housing stock.

Dan Garodnick

We are seeing, though, that the MIH rents are still comparable to what would be new housing that's built or sometimes much more affordable, and they also carry that permanent affordability.

Dan Garodnick

That being said, as I noted, at the commission, we certainly have the ability to make modifications and recommendations around the MIH levels that are selected.

Dan Garodnick

I think also in your proactive planning process, I think that's also where there's an opportunity to lay out the intentions, but also the tools that may need to be at the table outside of MIH to get the deeper affordability.

Kayla Santosuosso

And that was my next question was, is there a tool available in the arsenal if my proactive planning effort were to be successful where we could essentially...

Kayla Santosuosso

You know, through the rezoning, strongly advise or force a deeper level of affordability.

Dan Garodnick

Yeah, I think that there's, I think there's opportunity for that.

Dan Garodnick

There's also, again, and I would defer to my colleague at HPD, other housing financing tools, right, that can be utilized.

Dan Garodnick

I think the East New York example was shared earlier today, where we've achieved over 6,000 units, but really, really deep affordability.

Dan Garodnick

That's a combination of MIH, but also city.

Dan Garodnick

affordable housing tools, right?

Dan Garodnick

There's a mix.

Dan Garodnick

And so I think taking this proactive approach is helpful so that we could figure out the right mix in your community.