Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Council Member Lee asks about bad landlords proposing projects

New York City Council · Oct 21, 2026 · starts 1:52:44 · 2 min 11 sec

She asks if DCP factors in history of bad landlords; Garodnick says CPC reviews zoning appropriateness, and HPD takes enforcement seriously with programs like Fix the City.

Linda Lee

Okay, sorry, Chair, I just have one last question, if that's okay.

Linda Lee

And do you guys factor in, when you're looking at the proposals that you get, if there's history of bad landlords that are proposing these projects?

Linda Lee

Because I actually have examples of that in my district, where there are proposals being made, but the folks that are proposing it,

Linda Lee

haven't been good landlords with what they have now, right?

Linda Lee

And so I don't necessarily want to be in a position to say, yes, we need housing, but I don't want to reward bad behavior as well.

Linda Lee

And so what are some of the stopgap measures that are there in terms of how we can, you know, prevent that?

Dan Garodnick

Thank you for your question.

Dan Garodnick

So typically at the City Planning Commission, when we're reviewing an application, we are primarily making sure that the underlying zoning is appropriate for the community.

Dan Garodnick

Should the owner, landlord, anybody change over time, for instance, right?

Dan Garodnick

We need to make sure that it's a solid rationale for the community.

Dan Garodnick

That being said, we certainly have testimony from the public and are able to ensure that we're asking questions when it comes to who the potential operators are.

Dan Garodnick

But we also recognize that sometimes operators change over time.

Dan Garodnick

And so what's most important is making sure that the underlying.

Dan Garodnick

zoning makes sense for that neighborhood.

Dan Garodnick

That being said, there are certainly other tools in the city to ensure that landlords are good actors, as well as taking action against those landlords who are not.

Dan Garodnick

And so I'll certainly turn it to my colleagues at HPD to speak to that.

Michael Sandler

Yeah, I think that we take enforcement of tenants'rights and tenant conditions really seriously, and I think we're rolling out a lot of new programs in this administration.

Michael Sandler

I think my commissioner, Commissioner Levy, talks about putting bad landlords out of business, and I think she's serious when she says that.

Michael Sandler

And we're recently launching the Fix the City initiative, which is really supposed to tackle these longstanding bad landlords,

Michael Sandler

recognizing there are good landlords out there, that not all landlords are bad actors, but for those that are bad actors, we do want to enforce against them.

Michael Sandler

And if there are folks in your community that we should know about, we should connect.

Dan Garodnick

Actually, Commissioner Levy was very helpful, and she knew exactly who I was talking about when I brought her up.

Dan Garodnick

She knows all of them.

Dan Garodnick

Yes.

Dan Garodnick

Yeah.

Kevin C. Riley

Thank you, Councilmember.