Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

John Biggers of Charlotte Pipe and Foundry testifies on plastic piping

New York City Council · Oct 21, 2026 · starts 3:27:55 · 2 min 23 sec

He opposes plastic piping in tall buildings, cites fire safety concerns, and says height restrictions are common nationwide.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

That's tough to follow there.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

Chair Riley, thank you so much for allowing me to be here today.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

My name is John Biggers.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

I am president of Charlotte Pipe and Foundry Company.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

During my 37 years at Charlotte Pipe, I've covered New York City for 20 years.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

And I'm intimately familiar with the plumbing systems in New York City.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

Matter of fact, we might be able to help the lady with her TNP valve before this is over with.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

We'll have a conversation with her.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

Since 1901, Charlotte Pipe has been a family-owned American manufacturer of high-quality pipe and fittings.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

We're one of the nation's largest manufacturers of cast iron and plastic pipe and fittings, and we have extensive experience with both materials and an unwavering commitment to safety.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

I've traveled New York City today to express our opposition to the block-by-block proposal to expand the use of plastic pipe in buildings taller than five stories.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

These and similar restrictions exist nationwide due to the longstanding safety concerns.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

With more of a century of experience in manufacturing cast iron and plastic piping, Charlotte Pipe is in a unique position to speak on the risks of expanding plastic piping in large residential buildings.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

Fire safety is the primary concern.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

In buildings taller than five stories, evacuating residents can take more time, making fire protection especially critical.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

Plastic piping can melt, burn, and generate harmful gases during a fire.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

As you heard earlier, these systems rely completely on fire-stopping devices between wall and floor penetrations.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

Once concealed, these devices can be difficult to inspect, maintain, creating additional concerns for building safety.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

As well, these fire stopping manufacturers do

Member of the Public - John Biggers

do not warranty the performance of these products.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

for the life of their buildings.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

So I think it's important for the council to understand that height restrictions, they're not uncommon in the U.S.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

Lots of states have height restrictions, and we would urge the council to not expand the existing height restrictions in New York City.

Member of the Public - John Biggers

Thank you.