Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Joseph asks about criminal summonses and nuisance abatement cases

New York City Council · Oct 21, 2026 · starts 0:57:52 · 1 min 39 sec

Joseph says developers treat fines as a slap on the wrist and asks how many criminal summonses DOB has issued and tried; Tigani says DOB is exploring more aggressive use of criminal summonses and nuisance abatements with the Law Department, and Shamash reports 71 criminal court summonses issued this year versus 36 in 2025.

Ahmed Tigani

We are exploring, we have in the past, and we're exploring if we can, there's more aggressive use of criminal summonses and nuisance abatements, which is legal actions that we do in coordination with the law department.

Ahmed Tigani

They can be very difficult cases to bring forward and try.

Rita C. Joseph

How many have you tried this year?

Rita C. Joseph

How many have you issued and how many have you tried?

Ahmed Tigani

I think we can look up those numbers for you.

Rita C. Joseph

That would be great.

Ahmed Tigani

This year, so far, we've issued 71 criminal court summonses.

Ahmed Tigani

So as the commissioner mentioned, we are using that tool more and more.

Ahmed Tigani

Thanks in part to the additional staffing we received as a result of the proactive enforcement program we were discussing earlier.

Ahmed Tigani

That's compared to 36 in calendar year 2025.

Rita C. Joseph

How many of them were ever dismissed through the office?

Ahmed Tigani

I mean, this would be separate.

Ahmed Tigani

This is oaths being a different...

Ahmed Tigani

jurisdiction versus us going to Supreme Court with our criminal summonses and nuisance abatements.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Okay.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Thank you, Chair.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Thank you so much, Councilmember Joseph.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

And, yeah, just to echo the frustration, it's something that I face too.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

I've had, and this is anecdotal, but, you know, properties that have gone up completely that neighbors will say the whole thing was done, there was never paperwork put up, and nobody ever came.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

I mean, and then did they call 311?

Pierina Ana Sanchez

That was a question.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

But there's just a lot of work that happens, especially in the smaller projects, right, in the smaller sites that...

Pierina Ana Sanchez

There's a lot of concern around echoing that.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Thank you.