Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Zhuang presses on enforcement of unpermitted after-hours work

New York City Council · Oct 21, 2026 · starts 1:28:54 · 5 min 12 sec

Zhuang asks what punishment applies when contractors work without an after-hours variance, citing videos of work before 5 a.m. and after 9 p.m. at 2501 86th Street and workers without helmets; Tigani says DOB needs an inspector to witness and attest to violations and offers to coordinate scheduled inspections with her office to capture repeated off-hours activity.

Susan Zhuang

Thank you, Chair.

Susan Zhuang

And Commissioner, I have a question.

Susan Zhuang

So after our variance, some of you guys issued the variance.

Susan Zhuang

If you guys did not issue the variance, they're still doing the work.

Susan Zhuang

Is there any punishment?

Ahmed Tigani

Yes, if we're able to capture a contractor doing work outside of their allowed hours, then there are violations and other follow-up actions we could take as an agency.

Susan Zhuang

So you mean catch their activity there, you guys have an inspector come during that time?

Susan Zhuang

Yes.

Susan Zhuang

But the community have recordings saying during this time they have a 24-hour camera there.

Susan Zhuang

They start work before 5 o'clock in the morning and then still doing the work 9 o'clock at night.

Susan Zhuang

This happened in my district in 2024.

Susan Zhuang

Also recently, also this year, we called DOB, called 311.

Susan Zhuang

When 311, DOB come, it's only during work hours.

Susan Zhuang

So during not working hour, what's the plan?

Susan Zhuang

punishment and how the community reached to DOB?

Ahmed Tigani

So I can't speak to what the action of someone putting a camera on another person's property, but I can say that when we do get information about after work,

Ahmed Tigani

after work hours, we try to work with the community to triangulate and schedule inspections if we can and be able to go and capture that action if it's happening during an hour that makes sense for that violation.

Ahmed Tigani

Additionally, we work with your office, we work with other community groups, but we do need to have an inspector who is viewing the action and can attest to it to write the violation.

Susan Zhuang

Okay, because I actually personally sent to city administration some videos after hours that the same developer sent to on 2501 86th Street.

Susan Zhuang

They are coming on Palm Sunday night around 9 o'clock doing the work.

Susan Zhuang

And they also come Sunday doing the work.

Susan Zhuang

And they also come before 6 o'clock in the morning doing the work.

Susan Zhuang

It's all captured by community, and it's public information.

Susan Zhuang

Everyone knows that.

Susan Zhuang

You can find at least 10, 20 people testify that.

Susan Zhuang

And also for the...

Susan Zhuang

the worker safety.

Susan Zhuang

When the community worker going to do the construction doesn't wear helmets, who they should report to?

Ahmed Tigani

They should absolutely call 3-in-1 if they see any dangerous condition so that we can send one of the specialized units to go and inspect and see if something is not being done appropriately.

Ahmed Tigani

And as far as, just to go back to the after-hour variance question, I think our most successful collaborations on going after that is when we work with you or a community member and try to triangle if Sundays are typically where you're seeing the infraction happen.

Ahmed Tigani

If it's Tuesday, Wednesdays, and Thursdays before 7 a.m., we can absolutely plan with our resources in advance to have someone there to capture that.

Susan Zhuang

Because those people, they are playing games with the community.

Susan Zhuang

They don't respect the community at all.

Susan Zhuang

They can come in the middle of the night, start the work, and then they can come very late in the evening time, start the work.

Susan Zhuang

We called many times, but...

Susan Zhuang

We have videos, we have pictures, and the people don't wear helmets.

Susan Zhuang

I just checked my phone in May, just a few days ago, October.

Susan Zhuang

Some people come to 2501 86th Street, they don't wear helmets at all.

Susan Zhuang

They're going to construction sites.

Susan Zhuang

And I think the

Susan Zhuang

The community already reported 311.

Susan Zhuang

Nothing was done there.

Ahmed Tigani

I mean, we have done, as you know, and the community knows, we have done many inspections of the site of 2501.

Ahmed Tigani

That said, our obligation is to respond to all that 311 complaints that come forward.

Ahmed Tigani

So there's no limitation on how often we're going to be responsive and continue to evaluate things.

Ahmed Tigani

If there are particular...

Ahmed Tigani

Time slots or moments where you feel like this is repetitive action.

Ahmed Tigani

Right after this hearing, we can coordinate with your office and make sure that we're positioning our resources to be there where it's most actively happening.

Ahmed Tigani

We want to be helpful in capturing activity that shouldn't be happening and issue the violations if appropriate.

Susan Zhuang

Okay, thank you.

Susan Zhuang

Can we just send you pictures and tell you?

Ahmed Tigani

Again, we need to have an inspector who can evaluate that.

Ahmed Tigani

Everyone deserves due process in this issue, and so we have to make sure that we're respecting each right as well.

Susan Zhuang

Okay, thank you.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Thank you, Council Member Joanne.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

Council Member Wilson, with a follow-up.