Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Zhuang questions DEP and DOB asbestos enforcement at 2501 86th Street

New York City Council · Oct 21, 2026 · starts 0:44:40 · 3 min 1 sec

Council Member Susan Zhuang asks how DOB and DEP safety requirements are enforced, citing 2501 86th Street where a fraudulent asbestos report was filed and demolition proceeded; Tigani and Shamash say DEP identified false documents, issued a stop work order, and DOB followed suit until a new ACP-5 was issued.

Pierina Ana Sanchez

So next I'm going to call up Councilmember Zhuang, followed by Joseph, and then I will see if any other colleagues have questions, and then I'll come back for round two.

Susan Zhuang

Thank you, Chair.

Susan Zhuang

And also, I want to thank Commissioner working very hard, give us a very long testimony.

Susan Zhuang

And also, I have some questions.

Susan Zhuang

How are DOB and DEP safety requirements enforced?

Ahmed Tigani

So at different steps in the process, there may be DEP reviews, checkbox item in the approval of plans or permitting process.

Ahmed Tigani

Most commonly known is the ones referred to as species.

Ahmed Tigani

And so those are items that we need to get verification that those applications are submitted, are reviewed both by their staff and our staff before an application is allowed to move forward toward approval or permitting.

Susan Zhuang

Who are responsible checks whether or not safe protocol are followed?

Susan Zhuang

Like in my district, we have 21, 2501 86th Street.

Susan Zhuang

We have been raised a question about asbestos for

Susan Zhuang

couple years and then finally we got a stop order because we know the building was from

Susan Zhuang

1990 before 1990 definitely has a spet a spet still there and then there's a fraudulent report was submitted and then finally after

Susan Zhuang

months community calling for investigation.

Susan Zhuang

Finally, in April, you guys did the investigation saying there's asbestos there.

Susan Zhuang

But the report as asbestos is from a couple years ago.

Susan Zhuang

Why the report suddenly you find is fraudulent?

Ahmed Tigani

So I remember in March during the prelim hearing, you had raised these issues and provided us with leather.

Ahmed Tigani

And you're right, a couple of weeks later, we were able to review.

Ahmed Tigani

And when we found that there were conditions that need to be corrected, we work with.

Ahmed Tigani

We worked with our partners at DEP to see that was resolved.

Ahmed Tigani

I don't remember all the details of the issue, but I'm happy to come back with more details if you want to have.

Yegal Shamash

Very specifically, DEP reviewed the documents that...

Yegal Shamash

That were submitted as part of that letter, and they were the agency that identified that there were false documents filed with that filing, and they issued the stop work order on the site.

Yegal Shamash

Once they issued the stop work order on the site, Department of Buildings followed suit, and

Yegal Shamash

waited for a new ACP-5 to be issued by DEP.

Yegal Shamash

Once that happened, we were able to lift the stop work order.

Yegal Shamash

But we followed the stop work order issued by DEP.

Susan Zhuang

Okay, thank you.