Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Matt Weth calls Borden a detention facility with systemic failures

New York City Council · Oct 21, 2026 · starts 3:01:47 · 2 min 59 sec

Weth says Borden is not a residence but a holding or detention facility, says management failures run from the top down, staff are unsupervised, and there is no accountability.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

My name is Matt Weth.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

I was honorably discharged from the Air Force 2005.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

I had the unfortunate fortune of ending up at the Borden Avenue, as they call it, Veterans Residence, which I'd like to start right there.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

That's an open insult.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

The name of the facility, it's not a residence.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

At best, it's a holding facility.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

If I'm being honest about it, it feels much more like a detention facility.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

You asked my fellow veteran over here whether it was a couple issues or systemic.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

I like that I can look at Jody Rudin while I say this.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

It's decidedly systemic.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

Your organization's idea of what constitutes organizational management is an embarrassment to the concept itself.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

The problem is from the top down, and it's just rot exposed at every level.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

I have management experience, unfortunately for me, because I can see glaringly.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

You say lack of oversight?

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

Like, yeah, lack of oversight at every level.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

The, the, uh,

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

lowest ranked employees there, if you will.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

The bulk of the staff effectively operates with no supervision.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

I couldn't tell you what their duties are supposed to be.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

Collectively, they use their numbers to abscond from responsibility.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

I can tell you if you walked in that facility right now, you wouldn't have to even be able to get in.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

If you just went in those double glass doors and looked, because you can see the desk, you know from experience, Councilperson Murano, you can see what's going on.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

In front of the, you know, beyond the double glass doors.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

I can guarantee you there are at least three or four people sitting in that office behind the desk, socializing, doing nothing.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

And they're probably all supposed to be doing something.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

And there's no management.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

Nobody is watching them or holding them accountable.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

At any level for their lack of doing anything.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

And it's a complete embarrassment.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

It's a nightmare from top to bottom in an organizational sense that I was there last week at Julie Wan's attempt.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

I saw Councilperson Wong there as well.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

Julie Wan's pitiful attempt to enter the facility.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

I say pitiful attempt because

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

From what I can gather, it was her first attempt since she took office.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

I'm a veteran.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

If I'm showing up somewhere that I'm not 100% sure I can just walk right in, I'm going to test that out beforehand so as not to avoid the embarrassment that she walked right into.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

That was really embarrassing, frankly.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

Uh,

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

That you guys can't just get it together and get her in there whenever she needs to says a lot.

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

How's that?

Member of the Public - Matt Weth

I'll let that one speak for itself and let everyone else draw their own conclusions.