Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Remarks

Council Member De La Rosa explains vote on horse carriage bill

New York City Council · Oct 22, 2026 · starts 1:21:59 · 2 min 20 sec

Council Member Carmen De La Rosa discloses her daughter works for the Department of Education. She explains her vote in favor of Intro 943, arguing that protecting workers and animals are not competing values and that the city can do both.

Council Staff

De La Rosa.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Permission to explain my vote?

Council Staff

Permission granted.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Thank you.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Well, I have to disclose that the Department of Education is on the agenda on the transparency resolution.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

My daughter is associated with the Department of Education.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

As the former chair of the Labor Committee in this body and as someone who has been in elected office for 10 years next year,

Carmen N. De La Rosa

in 2027, I've spent most of my public service fighting for workers'rights, and that commitment weighs heavy on me today.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

But that commitment is also not to be questioned.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

I would not allow anyone to question my commitment to the workers of our city.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

So today, I am voting in favor of Intro 943 with the confidence

Carmen N. De La Rosa

that we will ensure that workers will be protected and that there is a just transition that will be prioritized and that the safety and the rights of animals will also be ensured by this vote.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Because we can do all those things at once.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

After decades of debate and advocacy and hearings, the status quo is not serving anyone anymore.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

In June,

Carmen N. De La Rosa

18-year-old tourist Romach Mahajan lost his life, and that is something that should bring pause to everyone.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Each incident endangers animals.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

the public workers whose lives depend on this industry.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

And tensions are high on every side of this issue, but delays serve none of us.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

I support this legislation, and I know and do not take lightly what it means to close this chapter.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

But there is a genuine commitment from the people in this room to make sure that the livelihoods of those impacted

Carmen N. De La Rosa

are prioritized.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Carriage drivers have built their lives on years of experience, specialized skills, and relationship with customers.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Many have paid out of pocket for medallions and equipment, and they are workers of our city, and they deserve to be treated as partners in this transition.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

We are committed to that.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

I want to thank Chair Shulman, Speaker Menon,

Carmen N. De La Rosa

and all of our colleagues who have listened to the debate and come up with a fair and balanced solution.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Protecting workers and protecting animals are not competing values, and today we choose to do both.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

I also want to take a moment to thank Sandy Nurse for her courage, for her conviction,

Carmen N. De La Rosa

for her balanced approach to ensuring that we are making a dent in the housing crisis.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Thank you, and I proudly vote aye on all.