Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Abreu questions DOT on cyclist fatalities and vehicle size

New York City Council · Oct 27, 2026 · starts 2:13:58 · 2 min 35 sec

Abreu returns to DOT and asks about the discrepancy between record-low overall fatalities and an 86% increase in cyclist fatalities. Flynn says traditional cyclists are trending down while e-bike and scooter fatalities are up. Abreu asks about larger, heavier vehicles; Flynn says DOT advocates for smaller vehicles and shifting freight to cargo bikes, rail, and waterways.

Shaun Abreu

So this administration has touted its Vision Zero progress, citing record lows in overall traffic fatalities.

Shaun Abreu

However, traffic fatalities are up 86% for cyclists.

Shaun Abreu

How does the administration explain this discrepancy?

Shaun Abreu

Are streets getting safer for car drivers but more dangerous for cyclists?

Mike Flynn

Thank you, Chair.

Mike Flynn

So I guess just to be clear, we're seeing an overall downward trend for traditional cyclists, where we've seen that growth this year is for e-bikes and stand-up scooters.

Mike Flynn

And that, as you know from the last hearing, is a big area of focus for us.

Mike Flynn

Generally speaking, what we've been seeing is...

Mike Flynn

Crashes and fatalities from what you

Mike Flynn

might call traditional users have been trending in the right direction.

Mike Flynn

And then as the industry evolves and things change, we have to keep evolving in response to those new challenges.

Shaun Abreu

Recent trends in vehicles, such as larger hood sizes and heavier overall weight, make cars safer for those driving them, but more deadly for other road users.

Shaun Abreu

What is DOT doing in terms of advocacy, education, or other investments to address this issue?

Shaun Abreu

I know we can't regulate size of vehicles in the city, but...

Shaun Abreu

The harm to folks on our streets is it's pretty big.

Mike Flynn

It's really alarming, Chair, yes.

Mike Flynn

And I know the New York Times, for example, did a really good article on this topic a few months back where they visualized the growth in the average vehicle size over the last few decades.

Mike Flynn

This is very much on our radar.

Mike Flynn

As you mentioned, it's something we have a little less control over, but we want to use our position to

Mike Flynn

advocate and to see where we do have some policy levers to really incentivize safer vehicles, which in general are smaller vehicles.

Madeline Labadie

And just to add, in terms of what's under DOT's control, obviously, you know, we're concerned about the role of the wear and tear on our assets as it relates to milling and paving and other repairs that need to be done.

Madeline Labadie

So we're thinking a lot about truck usage.

Madeline Labadie

So we are.

Madeline Labadie

We have a freight unit, and we are investing their work to help shift freight from large, heavy vehicles to other safer modes, such as cargo bikes, rail, and waterways through initiatives like the Blue Highways,

Madeline Labadie

and working with organizations such as IAHS to develop federal safety standards for freight vehicles as well to prioritize vulnerable road users.