Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Abreu asks BIC enforcement of side guard requirement

New York City Council · Oct 27, 2026 · starts 2:11:36 · 2 min 22 sec

Abreu asks how BIC enforces the side guard requirement for trucks without waivers. Crotty describes yard and garage visits, joint Operation Safe Drive inspections with NYPD and state partners, 99% compliance, and fewer than 80 violations. Abreu requests violation and license revocation data.

Shaun Abreu

And how does BIC enforce the side guard requirement for trucks that do not have a waiver?

Elizabeth Crotty

We are regularly engaged in a variety of enforcement measures.

Elizabeth Crotty

So we regularly visit the yards and garages of companies that we regulate.

Elizabeth Crotty

And if we see a vehicle that looks like it should have a side guard and it does not, we will review and see was there an appropriate waiver here.

Elizabeth Crotty

And if it was not, then that can result in a violation.

Elizabeth Crotty

We do joint operations with NYPD, with the state, and with other agencies across the entire city.

Elizabeth Crotty

Operation Safe Drive is what we call it, where we will pick a high-traffic corridor and we will pull over trucks and we'll do a full vehicle inspection to see, do they have a side guard if they need one?

Elizabeth Crotty

Do they have a convex mirror?

Elizabeth Crotty

Are they filling out their daily inspection safety reports?

Elizabeth Crotty

So there's a lot of in-the-field work that we do to check, is this truck following all the safety regulations it's supposed to?

Shaun Abreu

What is the number of violations, if you have any, for those?

Shaun Abreu

For those who do not have a waiver and were found to not have a side guard.

Elizabeth Crotty

That's data I would have to get back to you.

Shaun Abreu

I would also need that information.

Shaun Abreu

Do you know how many licenses have been revoked for those not having a side guard?

Elizabeth Crotty

I may be wrong, Chair, but my understanding is...

Elizabeth Crotty

One second.

Elizabeth Crotty

We have 99% compliance with the side guard waiver.

Elizabeth Crotty

So it would be very few where there have been violations of noncompliance with the side guard rule.

Elizabeth Crotty

It's been less than 80 over the past several years.

Elizabeth Crotty

We're talking about, again, 7,000 vehicles in the entire fleets that we oversee.

Elizabeth Crotty

Since the side guard rule went into effect, there have been less than 80 violations.

Elizabeth Crotty

So this demonstrates that the companies are either following the side guard rules.

Elizabeth Crotty

And we are working with them when we need an alternative like a modified side guard or a waiver.

Shaun Abreu

Thank you.

Elizabeth Crotty

Thank you.

Shaun Abreu

And I'll turn it over for questions for DOT.