Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Crotty explains other side guard waiver examples

New York City Council · Oct 27, 2026 · starts 2:06:50 · 2 min 5 sec

Crotty gives other side guard waiver examples, including dump trucks with tri-axles that cannot support side guards. She says BIC reviews each application individually, may request mechanics letters, and has revisited waivers to require modified side guards.

Shaun Abreu

So you were going into the bases for which BIC would issue side guard waivers, and this example is one of them.

Shaun Abreu

Are there other examples where a side guard exemption would be appropriate?

Elizabeth Crotty

Sure.

Elizabeth Crotty

Many of the trucks that fall under BIC's regulation are trucks that are used to remove construction and debris, not traditional waste, but we're talking about heavy-duty construction debris, and those are dump trucks.

Elizabeth Crotty

We regulate a large number of dump trucks.

Elizabeth Crotty

And if you look at the average dump truck, it doesn't just have a front axle, a rear axle, and lots of space in between.

Elizabeth Crotty

It usually has additional wheels, including something that's called a...

Elizabeth Crotty

like a third axle, a tri-axle, which is a wheel that is used to help the vehicle navigate uneven terrain.

Elizabeth Crotty

And so there's a series of these wheels.

Elizabeth Crotty

And a tri-axle vehicle, the vehicle moves in such a way that if you install a side guard,

Elizabeth Crotty

the side guard would break when the vehicle wheel turns or the wheel could get damaged.

Elizabeth Crotty

So one of the things that we require when we receive an application for a waiver is if we don't feel like we have enough information, we will ask the company for more.

Elizabeth Crotty

They may send us a mechanics letter that explains just what I explained to you, that the vehicle, the dump truck, for example, can't support a side guard.

Elizabeth Crotty

So that's one example of a type of vehicle that's different from the one involved at 14th Street.

Shaun Abreu

Does BIC ever revisit or reevaluate a waiver after it has been issued, and has it ever been rescinded at any moment?

Elizabeth Crotty

We have revisited waivers that have been granted, and what it's allowed us to do is have an iterative, ongoing conversation with the company.

Elizabeth Crotty

So we may take another look at where we've given a waiver and said, you know what, there is still a one-foot space, for example, between the step to the cab and that gas tank.

Elizabeth Crotty

And can you install a modified side guard in that limited space?

Elizabeth Crotty

And we will keep working with the company until they do so.

Elizabeth Crotty

And we've had success in that regard.