Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Abreu asks how many BIC trucks have side guard waivers

New York City Council · Oct 27, 2026 · starts 2:08:55 · 2 min 40 sec

Abreu asks how many trucks under BIC jurisdiction have side guard waivers. Crotty says BIC regulates about 7,000 trucks and about half have waivers, mostly dump trucks. Abreu asks for collision data involving waived trucks; Crotty does not have it and will follow up.

Shaun Abreu

Sounds like you know a lot about side guards.

Shaun Abreu

How many trucks under a BICS jurisdiction currently have a waiver?

Elizabeth Crotty

Okay, so we have about 7,000 trucks under our...

Shaun Abreu

Sorry, say that again?

Elizabeth Crotty

We have about 7,000 trucks that are under our jurisdiction, that we have licensed, that we've given plates to.

Elizabeth Crotty

As I mentioned, the largest share of that are not traditional trash trucks that you throw a garbage bag into.

Elizabeth Crotty

The largest share are C&D, construction and demolition, what we call Class 2 vehicles.

Elizabeth Crotty

These are the heavy-duty vehicles.

Elizabeth Crotty

And most of those Class 2 vehicles are dump trucks.

Elizabeth Crotty

And those dump trucks, like I said, often have additional axles.

Elizabeth Crotty

So about half of the vehicles that we regulate have waivers.

Elizabeth Crotty

So those are these dump trucks.

Shaun Abreu

Okay.

Shaun Abreu

All right, so you're saying of the waivers given, most of them are dump trucks?

Elizabeth Crotty

Of the waivers given, the largest share are dump trucks.

Shaun Abreu

What are some other type of exemptions given for non-dump trucks?

Elizabeth Crotty

So, right.

Elizabeth Crotty

So the vehicle that was involved in the 14th Street incident, for example, was not a dump truck.

Elizabeth Crotty

It was a truck that had this, my understanding, and please correct me if I'm wrong, like a high-powered vacuum that's used, involved to kind of clean up street debris when there's construction or tearing up of a street.

Elizabeth Crotty

That had a toolbox and it had a fuel tank in that area.

Elizabeth Crotty

And that's why it couldn't support a side guard.

Elizabeth Crotty

There are many different designs of trucks.

Elizabeth Crotty

I don't want to give you broad categories.

Elizabeth Crotty

Dump truck is the easiest category because many of them do have those features I mentioned.

Elizabeth Crotty

But there can be a host of types of vehicles on the road where the manufacturer who builds the vehicle decides to put things underneath the truck in those spaces.

Shaun Abreu

Do you know how many of those trucks that were granted waivers have been involved in collisions with pedestrians or cyclists since 2023?

Elizabeth Crotty

I do not have that information.

Shaun Abreu

Or how it compares to those with not being granted a waiver.

Elizabeth Crotty

It's a good question, Chair.

Elizabeth Crotty

I will see if we have the data that allows us to break it down that way with respect to collision involvement and whether they had a side guard or a waiver.

Elizabeth Crotty

We'll have to get back to you.

Shaun Abreu

I think it's slightly disappointing to not have that information.

Shaun Abreu

Very disappointing, actually, to not have that information.

Shaun Abreu

Please get it to us as soon as you can.