Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Chair Hudson questions Deborah Berkman on safety transfer process

New York City Council · Oct 28, 2026 · starts 3:04:17 · 1 min 45 sec

Hudson asks whether Berkman contacts site staff or DHS. Berkman says she contacts DHS legal, but clients have already tried at the shelter and been denied or ignored. Hudson says lawyers should not be needed for safety transfers.

Crystal Hudson

Thank you so much for your testimony.

Crystal Hudson

And I just want to ask, when you've advocated on behalf of clients, is that like directly with the security officers or management at the site, or is it with DHS?

Member of the Public - Deborah Berkman

So I generally will contact DHS legal because I'm a lawyer and the people on my team work with DHS legal.

Member of the Public - Deborah Berkman

And there is still at times opposition when we bring up a safety request.

Crystal Hudson

I mean, so you're an attorney.

Member of the Public - Deborah Berkman

I am.

Crystal Hudson

Okay, don't take offense.

Member of the Public - Deborah Berkman

Oh.

Crystal Hudson

But just because I feel like lawyers talking to lawyers is always going to be a little...

Member of the Public - Deborah Berkman

You shouldn't need a lawyer.

Member of the Public - Deborah Berkman

Challenging.

Crystal Hudson

You shouldn't need a lawyer, and I totally support that.

Crystal Hudson

But I just wonder if the lawyers are saying something that could be maybe a little bit different from what...

Crystal Hudson

other folks in DHS could potentially say.

Member of the Public - Deborah Berkman

Right, what programs would say.

Member of the Public - Deborah Berkman

What I will say is that we would never request a safety transfer for a client unless they had already requested it themselves and not gotten anywhere.

Member of the Public - Deborah Berkman

So 100% of our safety transfer requests, the clients have already tried.

Member of the Public - Deborah Berkman

To bring it up at their shelter and it hasn't been denied.

Member of the Public - Deborah Berkman

It's been denied or it hasn't been processed.

Member of the Public - Deborah Berkman

It's not clear to me.

Crystal Hudson

Yeah.

Crystal Hudson

And I guess also what I'm, the point that I'm trying to make is, and probably not in the best or most articulate way, is the lawyers probably shouldn't be the people making the decision or determination as to whether or not somebody should be

Crystal Hudson

moved for safety reasons.

Member of the Public - Deborah Berkman

Of course.

Member of the Public - Deborah Berkman

And if someone feels unsafe, then there is a safety threat.

Crystal Hudson

Right.

Crystal Hudson

Exactly.

Crystal Hudson

Okay.

Crystal Hudson

Thank you.

Member of the Public - Deborah Berkman

Thank you.