Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Chair Hudson questions DHS on security contractor conflicts and oversight

New York City Council · Oct 28, 2026 · starts 1:37:42 · 3 min 15 sec

Hudson reads an email from a city employee alleging discrepancies in reporting and a security contractor retained despite a DHS recommendation not to renew. Fellini says DHS investigates impropriety and may refer to DOI.

Crystal Hudson

I would like to share.

Crystal Hudson

an email that I received, and I'm going to do my best to redact lots of the information.

Crystal Hudson

There were some specifics that were provided in an attempt to protect this person's identity, but

Crystal Hudson

they have, they are a New York City employee who has elevated several security concerns with a single shelter provider, including one matter that they believed warranted referral to DOI

Crystal Hudson

after they identified discrepancies between what was reported to DHS and what they were able to observe through records.

Crystal Hudson

And DHS security personnel had provided, had recommended that the provider not renew with the same security contractor due to ongoing concerns.

Crystal Hudson

And though that recommendation was known to staff, the contractor was still retained.

Crystal Hudson

And so I'm wondering, broadly speaking, what type of oversight structure and safeguards exist to prevent conflicts of interest, preferential treatment, or inappropriate relationships

Crystal Hudson

with contracted providers and city leadership?

Crystal Hudson

And, you know, we've...

Crystal Hudson

Been through

Crystal Hudson

a lot of this in the last mayoral administration.

Crystal Hudson

And so just want to make sure we have some real transparency around processes that you all have in place to identify inappropriate, you know, instances like this.

Christine Clarke

Thank you.

Christine Clarke

These are serious allegations.

Christine Clarke

So if I heard you correctly, there were discrepancies in the records and things reported to DHS as well as concerns about the security contractor.

Crystal Hudson

Correct.

Christine Clarke

That were raised to DHS.

Christine Clarke

Yeah.

Christine Clarke

When we are made aware, either directly through an incident, through a complaint, through an anonymous source of any impropriety, we investigate.

Christine Clarke

So we will do some due diligence within DHS before making sure that we get that right over to DSS Legal, to the Office of Regulatory Compliance, to our ACCO, to do the legal and contractual steps that they do.

Christine Clarke

Okay.

Christine Clarke

Which may also result in a referral to DOI.

Crystal Hudson

Right.

Crystal Hudson

Okay.

Crystal Hudson

It's possible, I don't know with certainty, but it's possible that this may have already been referred to DOI, but I suppose you and I will both find out in due time.

Christine Clarke

Yeah, and we certainly welcome working with DOI.

Christine Clarke

It's a resource to us to take investigations to a further place.

Christine Clarke

I don't want to belabor the point, but is it worth an X?

Erin Dalton

explanation of the ways in which our providers contract with subcontractors and our role in that?

Crystal Hudson

Yeah, I think that's, now would be an appropriate time.