Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Council Member Ung questions panel on language access in shelters

New York City Council · Oct 28, 2026 · starts 0:30:35 · 2 min 16 sec

Ung asks about language capabilities. Insfran says he can speak English but cannot write it, and other Spanish-speaking residents relied on him to translate because staff did not provide language help.

Crystal Hudson

Thank you.

Crystal Hudson

And Councilmember Nurse?

Crystal Hudson

Oh, Councilmember Ong?

Sandra Ung

I do have a question for the last gentleman.

Sandra Ung

What was the language capabilities of the shelter?

Sandra Ung

Because, you know, what, like he's talking to you now through a translator.

Sandra Ung

Was there someone like that in the shelter for him?

Sandra Ung

How did he address his concerns?

Sandra Ung

Like who was in the shelter that can speak the language?

Sandra Ung

Did you say like a language line?

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

No, exactly.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

I can talk in English.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

So my complaint is I can't write in English.

Crystal Hudson

Sorry, just pull the microphone a little bit closer, please.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

That I said that I can talk in English.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

I can express my angry or my disagreement by talking.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

So I don't have problem to communicate my concern in the shelter.

Member of the Public

Yes, Miss Sandra.

Member of the Public

He speaks English.

Member of the Public

For example, it's not perfect, but he speaks really well.

Member of the Public

Oh, my apologies.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

He speaks English, and he can talk in English with the people in the shelter, but I think he feels like he was ignored by those people.

Member of the Public

Sure.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

Yes.

Sandra Ung

I mean, did you, was, for people who could speak English less capable than you, was there any, did you see that, was there any, you know, language help there?

Sandra Ung

Anyone in the shelter that was helpful?

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

No, exactly.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

What happened is every opportunity that one resident had problems with communication because he's Spanish speaking, they usually, can you help me please?

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

What he's saying, blah, blah, blah.

Member of the Public - Francisco Insfran

So I can help them to translate whatever they need to say at the moment.

Sandra Ung

So they're basically counting on you to help them.

Sandra Ung

Exactly.

Sandra Ung

Okay.

Sandra Ung

Exactly.

Sandra Ung

All right.

Sandra Ung

Thank you.

Sandra Ung

Thank you.

Sandra Ung

Thank you all.

Sandra Ung

Thank you, council members.

Sandra Ung

Thank you, public advocate.