Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Gabriella testifies on theft, gaslighting, and lack of accountability

New York City Council · Oct 28, 2026 · starts 3:31:07 · 3 min 16 sec

Gabriella, who has autism, says a roommate stole belongings and staff gaslighted him. He says there is no accountability and residents are told to just deal with it.

Crystal Hudson

Gabriella?

Member of the Public

Sorry about that.

Member of the Public

The back.

Member of the Public

I have a bad back.

Member of the Public

I'm not sure.

Crystal Hudson

That's okay.

Member of the Public

Okay.

Member of the Public

Thank you.

Member of the Public

The more respect from staff would also go a long way, as would real accountability for issues and complaints.

Member of the Public

Often situations with shelter staff or other residents escalate.

Member of the Public

after residents have made repeated complaints, with no real accountability from shelter providers or the ombudsman's office.

Member of the Public

People often reach out to the ombudsman's office without a response or meaningful resolution or accountability.

Member of the Public

Another important recommendation is housing first.

Member of the Public

We need to move from an ever-expanding shelter system to a housing first model where we are quickly placing people in permanent housing instead of having them linger in shelter for years while their frustration and time in the system builds.

Member of the Public

The $4 billion spent on shelters should be used to allow people to move into permanent housing as quickly as possible.

Member of the Public

You see...

Member of the Public

I, my mood in my most recent shot, I've been with Safety Net for a few months.

Member of the Public

Probably June, July thing.

Member of the Public

I've been homeless for a few months, top of that.

Member of the Public

I have autism, you see.

Member of the Public

And they moved in the shelter with people like schizophrenia.

Member of the Public

My thing is not as bad as theirs.

Member of the Public

You know what I mean?

Member of the Public

As well, yeah, there's no accountability.

Member of the Public

They just do what the security guards did.

Member of the Public

You just do what I want, and you just have to deal with it.

Member of the Public

I have a roommate, like, recently, who a few weeks ago, within a couple weeks, like, kept stealing my stuff and saying gaslighting me.

Member of the Public

And it's like your guards also gaslighting you, thinking that it wasn't stolen or it wasn't yours or it wasn't there.

Member of the Public

Same thing as my roommate.

Member of the Public

Like, their stuff got, the phone had stolen, and then they proceeded to steal my stuff.

Member of the Public

Like, you have to stop to deal with it or get a new one.

Member of the Public

You couldn't get your old one back.

Member of the Public

Yeah.

Crystal Hudson

Sorry, just to clarify.

Crystal Hudson

When your personal items were stolen, you were instructed to get new, or it was your phone specifically?

Member of the Public

No, no.

Member of the Public

Hold on.

Member of the Public

No, it wasn't.

Member of the Public

I don't have a phone.

Member of the Public

What I mean is when my roommate was living in their previous apartment, like their previous roommates told me.

Member of the Public

Okay.

Member of the Public

And because of that, but despite knowing, me telling, they telling me that, that story, they proceed to steal my stuff.

Member of the Public

You know, they don't understand.

Member of the Public

Like, they're doing to me what was done to them.

Member of the Public

Right.

Member of the Public

They don't get that.

Crystal Hudson

But what I'm asking is, you were told by shelter staff.

Crystal Hudson

To get a new item instead of...

Member of the Public

Like, they looked into...

Member of the Public

Yes, they looked into it and they said, eh, this stuff isn't there, or it's not real, or it's actually theirs.

Member of the Public

Like, gaslighting.

Crystal Hudson

Okay, I understand.

Member of the Public

Or get a new one.

Member of the Public

It's probably not there.

Crystal Hudson

Thank you.

Crystal Hudson

Thank you.

Crystal Hudson

Thank you all for your testimonies.

Crystal Hudson

We'll definitely be sure to follow up directly.

Crystal Hudson

Thank you.