Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Jorge Jimenez testifies on grievance process loopholes

New York City Council · Oct 28, 2026 · starts 3:13:08 · 4 min 3 sec

Jimenez says he tried for five months to file a grievance but could not get an email address and faced tactical avoidance. He says contracts and performance reviews create incentives to suppress grievances and calls for more social workers.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

I'm here to support 307.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

I consider it extremely important, but I think there's a point that is being restated every time we talk.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

It's the fact that the majority of the issues that are affecting people

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

are usually related to grievances that cannot be reported.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

There's actually a lot of conversation about huge words like homicide, rape, grand larceny, or theft, or things like this.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

But mainly, one of the problems that we're experiencing is that there's some sort of tactical avoidance.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

And plausible deniability that can be created when a process of grievances is not well established.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

That's why I feel, and actually I'm going through a process like that right now.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

I've been trying to report a grievance for the past five months, and I have actually followed the specific hierarchy of things that I had to do with the specific

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

children provider, in this case, a drop-in center provider.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

And pretty much what I've done, it leads to nothing.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

I keep entering a loophole that is full of tactical avoidance, implosible deniability, and then there's some specific little tricks that happen.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

One of them being

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

You have to send us an email.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

But how can I send you an email to start the process if your staff never provides emails, email addresses to contact them?

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

I cannot start the process if you don't provide me with that.

Crystal Hudson

Is there not a general email address or line to submit grievances?

Crystal Hudson

No.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

Pretty much what you must do is try to guess.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

Guess the first letter of the worker, the last name, and then you put at whatever organization you're with, and maybe that becomes...

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

The way you deal with that trick.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

That's one of the tricks.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

There's another one.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

The other trick is the let's have a conversation about this.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

Well, the conversations cannot be tracked down because it disappears.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

It becomes a conversation.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

There are other tricks that happen, and these are usually correlated to one specific thing.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

I'm not sure.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

These are contracts.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

And these contracts have to be reviewed every year for performance.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

A huge amount of grievances can actually lead to a decrease in the qualification that they receive every year, from excellent to good to average.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

Some of these contracts are for like millions of dollars over five years.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

Too many complaints, let's not use the word complaint, too many grievances, reports can lead to that.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

We're forgetting two aspects, the business aspect of this part.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

And another aspect that we're forgetting is the human factor.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

One central position, one central type of professional that we're missing.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

of the social worker.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

We don't need more case managers.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

That's an euphemism that is being used financially in order to avoid hiring social workers that have been trained to deal with this multiplicity of issues.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

But social workers are expensive.

Crystal Hudson

Can I just ask you a question?

Crystal Hudson

For the complaints or grievances that you've submitted, are you saying that you've not received any sort of formal response?

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

It was impossible for me to start the process because I did not have the email.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

Then I found the email through a process.

Crystal Hudson

But there's no like box or anything on site where you can just submit.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

And then what happened is I actually found the email.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

I sent an email to the case manager, but that case manager never answered.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

So that's the other trick.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

If they don't answer, there is no continuity of service in order to establish a bridge that will actually lead to a proper grievances report.

Crystal Hudson

Okay.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

And it's premeditated.

Member of the Public - Jorge Jimenez

Thank you.

Crystal Hudson

Yeah.

Crystal Hudson

Thank you so much for your testimony.

Crystal Hudson

We'll follow up with you directly as well.

Crystal Hudson

Thank you.