Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Agency Testimony

CFB testimony - Ryan on implementation costs and timeline

New York City Council · Jun 22, 2026 · starts 0:39:53 · 49 sec

Ryan warns that implementing the bill would require significant resources and at least a year after passage, including updating existing reporting systems and building a new internal system to receive and publish provenance data and ad information from candidates and independent spenders.

Paul Seamus Ryan

For that reason, we are relatively confident in our ability to implement this new mandate, though significant resources and time will be required.

Paul Seamus Ryan

We have formed an agency-wide AI working group, and we are learning more every day.

Paul Seamus Ryan

Shifting the strategy to a disclosure model means the council would be placing an entirely new administrative and enforcement mandate onto the campaign finance board.

Paul Seamus Ryan

Nevertheless, AI technology is evolving at such a rapid pace that we cannot say with certainty how best to regulate its use in elections.

Paul Seamus Ryan

We want to be realistic about the timeline and resources that would be required to implement this legislation.

Paul Seamus Ryan

To that end, we appreciate that the amended version of this legislation meaningfully addresses our most significant legal and implementation concerns shared at the hearing in December 2024.

Paul Seamus Ryan

We are still researching the exact technology and staffing costs associated with implementing the bill, but we anticipate that the cost would be steep and that it would take, at a minimum, a year to implement after bill passage.

Paul Seamus Ryan

By shifting from a prohibition to a disclosure model and naming the CFB as the agency in receipt of these disclosures, as well as naming the CFB as the agency responsible for implementing the new disclosure regime,

Paul Seamus Ryan

This estimate includes both updating our existing candidate and independent spending reporting systems and building an entirely new internal system to receive

Paul Seamus Ryan

the Council eliminated the greatest vulnerabilities to First Amendment legal challenge and clarified administrative and enforcement responsibilities.

Paul Seamus Ryan

and to make public the provenance data and other similar ad information we would be receiving from candidates and independent spenders.

Paul Seamus Ryan

The CFB has a unique perspective on this topic rooted in our dual mandate to serve candidates and voters.