Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Carolina Roberts (animal rights advocate) testifies supporting ban

New York City Council · Jul 15, 2026 · starts 6:00:10 · 3 min 37 sec

Carolina Roberts, an actress and animal rights advocate from Mexico City, testifies about documenting carriage horses in Central Park, witnessing their poor conditions, and experiencing harassment from a carriage driver for advocating.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

Thank you so much.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

Good afternoon, Chair and members of the Council.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

My name is Carolina Roberts, also known as Rocky in the animal rights community.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

I'm an actress and I'm an animal rights advocate and I traveled here from Mexico City because I believe these horses deserve a voice and should not suffer for human entertainment.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

For years, I have documented New York City's carriage horses while speaking up for many other animals who cannot speak for themselves.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

Like the bulls in Mexico who are victims of the bullfighting.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

New York has always led by example.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

Humane alternatives already exist.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

We don't need horse-drawn carriages to welcome visitors.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

I also recognize that the men and women who work in this industry deserve respect.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

This is not about punishing workers.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

It's about creating a safer, more humane future for both horses and people through a transition of modern alternatives.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

I have spent countless hours in Central Park observing these horses, photographing them and filming them, speaking with tourists and witnessing this industry firsthand.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

I have stood beside New York City's carriage horses.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

I have seen them standing for hours on hard pavement, surrounded by traffic, noise, heat, and crowds, breathing exhaust fumes while pulling heavy carriages.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

These horses never chose this life.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

Ramanj Mahajan should still be alive.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

His tragic death reminds us that this industry not only endangers horses, but put human lives at risk.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

I have also experienced harassment while peacefully advocating for these horses.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

My friends and I

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

have been physically confronted by a violent carriage man who left his horse unattended, simply for expressing concern for their welfare.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

Today, you have the opportunity to protect these horses and help move New York toward a safer, more compassionate future.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

I respectfully ask you to pass Romancia's law and bring an end to horse-drawn carriages in New York City.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

And please send these horses to a sanctuary where they belong.

Member of the Public - Carolina Roberts

Muchisimas gracias.

Lynn C. Schulman

Thank you so much.

Lynn C. Schulman

To this panel, you're dismissed.

Lynn C. Schulman

The next panel is Helen David, Mary Irby.

Lynn C. Schulman

Herbie.

Lynn C. Schulman

Allison Bowling.

Lynn C. Schulman

Jim Keene, Mel Solowski, Susan Wagner.

Lynn C. Schulman

Jamie Baldanza.

Lynn C. Schulman

Can you also fill out a slip, please?

Lynn C. Schulman

Okay.

Lynn C. Schulman

He can join the panel when he gets here.

Lynn C. Schulman

I'm sorry, can you fill out another one?

Lynn C. Schulman

Okay, thank you.

Lynn C. Schulman

You may begin and identify yourself for the record, whoever wants to begin.