Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Giovanni Vallone (carriage owner) testifies opposing ban

New York City Council · Jul 15, 2026 · starts 6:34:08 · 1 min 39 sec

Giovanni Vallone, second-generation carriage owner, testifies about his 37 years in the business, his father's 65 years, and organizing a Columbus Day parade with Sicilian carts. He asks the council not to end their business.

Member of the Public - Giovanni Vallone

Good afternoon.

Member of the Public - Giovanni Vallone

My name is Giovanni Vallone.

Member of the Public - Giovanni Vallone

I'm the second generation of a family of carriage owners and drivers.

Member of the Public - Giovanni Vallone

My father started 65 years ago, and I continue his business with the happiness and with the principles.

Member of the Public - Giovanni Vallone

I was raised to respect my horse and respect the customers and see all my customers happy getting out from the carriage.

Member of the Public - Giovanni Vallone

I know about horses a lot because it's 37 years I'm here in this business and I'm the last member of the family with my cousin actually that's 30 years in this business and we also always respect everything.

Member of the Public - Giovanni Vallone

We try to respect all the rules and follow all the rules, respect all the people.

Member of the Public - Giovanni Vallone

And also another thing I want to say, three years ago, I was a promoter of a parade for the Columbus Day with seven Sicilian carts and seven New York horses that did a really great job.

Member of the Public - Giovanni Vallone

job and we were a lot of cities, big cities in the United States was jealous than what we did in New York because it was a big thing.

Member of the Public - Giovanni Vallone

Seven horses from New York horses and seven Sicilian cars that come all the way from Bagheria that if you check is the base where they always do the Sicilian cars.

Member of the Public - Giovanni Vallone

I don't know if you never heard about it.

Member of the Public - Giovanni Vallone

I also want to ask you to please sell our business or try to help us, you know, after 65 years for a family.

Member of the Public - Giovanni Vallone

It's a little bit kind of hard.

Lynn C. Schulman

Okay.

Lynn C. Schulman

Thank you.

Lynn C. Schulman

Natalie?