Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Melissa Pellicera (One Kind World) testifies remotely supporting ban

New York City Council · Jul 15, 2026 · starts 8:47:14 · 2 min 25 sec

Melissa Pellicera of One Kind World Foundation testifies remotely supporting the ban, arguing horses' freedom has been stolen, that longevity doesn't confer moral legitimacy, and that human alternatives exist.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

Yes, good evening, ma'am.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

Can you hear me?

Lynn C. Schulman

Yes.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

Wonderful.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

Thank you so much.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

Good evening, Chair Shulman, Speaker Manin, Council Member Murtay, members of the committee.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

I'm sorry that I could not attend in person.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

My name is Melissa Pellisera.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

I'm the founder of One Kind World Foundation, and I respectfully urge you to pass Intro 0943, Romach Law.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

It has been mentioned multiple times today that horses are prey animals.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

They have survived by perceiving danger and fleeing from it.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

No regulation or reinforcement mechanism can override millions of years of evolution.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

They are meant to traverse vast landscapes, forage freely, and live within enduring family bands.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

It is their inviolable right to be born and to live free, and we have stolen this right from them.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

Every human enterprise built upon the use of horses begins with the same assumption, that another living being's freedom may be subordinated to our desires.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

There is a reason the traditional expression is to break a horse.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

Before a horse can serve our purpose, its own will must first be overcome.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

Throughout this hearing, it was suggested that those of us who defend animals seek to remove them from human lives.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

That misunderstands our position entirely.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

We do not seek to remove them from human lives.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

remove horses from the human story.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

We seek to remove oppression from theirs.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

Let us call this what it is.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

It is animal exploitation.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

These are magnificent sentient beings, and they were never ours to use.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

Their lives belong to them.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

It was said today that horse-drawn carriages have been part of New York City since 1858.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

History is not only a record of traditions we preserve, it is also a record of practices humanity eventually found the courage to abandon.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

Longevity has never conferred moral legitimacy.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

Human alternatives exist.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

We have the ingenuity and compassion.

Lynn C. Schulman

Time expired.

Lynn C. Schulman

You have to summarize because we've got to move on.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

Thank you, ma'am.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

I just wanted to thank you for your time today.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

And that's it.

Member of the Public - Melissa Pellicera

Thank you so very much.

Lynn C. Schulman

You're very welcome.

Lynn C. Schulman

Thank you.

Lynn C. Schulman

Next is Jennifer Garrett.

Lynn C. Schulman

You may begin.