Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Monica Sharma testifies remotely supporting ban

New York City Council · Jul 15, 2026 · starts 8:44:29 · 2 min 46 sec

Monica Sharma testifies remotely supporting the ban, arguing human life cannot be compared to horse life but all lives matter, and that if your livelihood causes someone's death, change it.

Lynn C. Schulman

You may begin.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

Thank you for staying so late.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

I've been online since 10 a.m.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

And I appreciate what's going on over here.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

I just want, like everything has almost been covered by everybody who's been talking and I totally am in support of this bill, but I'm so amazed, you know, that

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

I understand this was originally for the welfare and the well-being of horses.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

I am a pet lover myself.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

I have two rescue dogs.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

I have two dogs in the past that we've lost.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

But I cannot compare the life of my son to a life of my pet.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

And I love my pets as much as you can think.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

It's just come down to a human life being in the part of a horse, you know, well-being.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

I don't know how we're comparing the two.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

It's very unfortunate.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

I just hope no mother ever has to think, you know, is my son the same importance as a...

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

Horse on a street.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

Horse lives are very important.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

Dog lives, extremely important.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

Any pet, any life, extremely important.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

Everyone has a right to live.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

But don't bring human life down to, you know, thinking with the horses.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

It's really, really not comparable.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

It's sad that, you know, it happened the way it did happen.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

Everyone has a right to get a...

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

Fair living, you know,

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

They have a right to livelihood.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

They should completely be able to achieve whatever dream they have.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

And it's wrong of them to say that they cannot adapt to a new lifestyle or adapt to a thing.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

Everybody adapts to everything.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

We've been through three different businesses in a lifetime, three different careers.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

After my children, I started something else.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

Before my life, I had something else.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

Everyone changes.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

Everyone evolves.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

Everyone can continue to grow into something else.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

If your livelihood is a reason for somebody's death, change it.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

It's not worth it.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

We are all going to die one day.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

But, you know, I would be.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

Devastated to know that because of me or my business.

Lynn C. Schulman

Time is up and if you want to just summarize in a couple of sentences, that's fine.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

I'm just in support of the bill.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

I'm a lot in support of the bill.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

This bill should definitely be passed.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

And I appreciate all the councilmen over here and the councilwomen and everybody here who's been so respectful and patient.

Member of the Public - Monica Sharma

But I must say that Councilman Gennaro was very rude to the people who did not support him.

Lynn C. Schulman

I hear you.

Lynn C. Schulman

We have to move on.

Lynn C. Schulman

Thank you.

Lynn C. Schulman

Melissa Pellicer.

Member of the Public - Pauline Burns

You may begin.

Lynn C. Schulman

Melissa Pellis.