Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Una Rose (Toronto activist) testifies remotely supporting ban

New York City Council · Jul 15, 2026 · starts 8:24:19 · 2 min 50 sec

Una Rose, an animal rights activist from Toronto, testifies remotely about boycotting NYC for 15 years until carriages are banned, proposes electric carriages as replacements, and references ASPCA founder Henry Bergh's legacy.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

Hi, can you hear me?

Council Staff

Yes.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

Okay.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

Okay.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

Hi, my name is Una.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

I'm from Toronto and I'm a long time animal rights activist and I'm speaking today on behalf of carriage horses and to give my support to the passing of Roma Lux Law and to ban the use of carriage horses in New York City.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

It is very important that this ban be passed and all these beautiful horses be retired to reputable sanctuaries and other non-working, loving, forever homes.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

They all deserve a nice retirement and that could easily be arranged by the city working together with aligned activists and welfare groups for all of them.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

For the drivers, the city could purchase electric carriages, which other cities around the world have.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

They're really popular.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

They look like a lot of fun, and they're green, so they're electric.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

So they would be green as well.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

Historically, passing this bill would be furthering the proud history of New York City as a leader in animal welfare.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

ASPCA was founded by a New Yorker, Henry Berg, in early 1800s, who would walk the streets of New York City berating drivers who abused, neglected, or forced sick animals to work.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

This decision, passing this bill, would confirm New York City is not only a great city for people, but also a great progressive one for animals as well.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

And finally, as a tourist, I long to visit New York City.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

I live in Toronto, so it's not much of a journey, but I can.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

I made a pledge to myself about 15 years ago I would not visit New York City until the carriage horse industry was banned.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

So it's been 15 years and four mayors, and I'm still waiting for that.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

It's just, it would be too depressing to go into beautiful Central Park and see these horses that all look sad.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

They look bored.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

They look like just full of, just miserable.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

That would ruin my trip.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

So I said, no, I'm not going to do it.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

I'm not going to support a city that supports this kind of animal abuse.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

So crew of kindness to animals is deep.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

Time expired.

Lynn C. Schulman

Just to summarize your end.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

Okay, so let's not let the heroism and tragedy of the young man who died be ignored and denied, and let's not let this bill be delayed and postponed any further.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

Let's get this bill passed and let's ban this cruelty because it's the right, smart, and kind thing to do for animals, for horses, for New Yorkers, for tourists, and for New York City.

Member of the Public - Una Rose

Thank you.

Lynn C. Schulman

Thank you very much.

Lynn C. Schulman

Sherry Ramsey.

Council Staff

You may begin.

Lynn C. Schulman

Sherry Ramsey.

Council Staff

You may begin.