Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Chair Ung Q&A: Mangin on council input in BSA proceedings

New York City Council · Sep 1, 2026 · starts 1:31:02 · 1 min 22 sec

Ung notes the Council has no formal role in BSA decisions and asks how Mangin would weigh council member input. Mangin commits to a completely open door policy, taking council input into careful consideration within BSA's legal constraints.

Sandra Ung

Thank you for your testimony.

Sandra Ung

So we're just going to start with my questions, then the committee members'questions, and then we'll go to other members.

Sandra Ung

So first, members of the council can wait in a BSA proceeding just like any other person can.

Sandra Ung

But we also know that the council does not have any decision-making powers over the matters that go before BSA, correct?

John Mangin

No direct decision-making powers, that's correct.

Sandra Ung

So what is your view of the way that should be given a court to any input for a local council member about BSA project that is in their local community in relation to whether a BSA should approve a project?

John Mangin

Thank you for that question.

John Mangin

I mean, at BSA, I would have a completely open door policy with respect to any input from council members on projects that affect their district.

John Mangin

Community board review is built in to virtually every BSA action as well.

John Mangin

And while, as we discussed,

John Mangin

BSA actions are typically very legally constrained.

John Mangin

You know, if you meet the findings, it gets approved.

John Mangin

If you don't meet the findings, you may not approve it.

John Mangin

Within that tightly cabined discretion, I would promise to take into careful consideration the input of any council members on those actions.

Sandra Ung

Thank you.