Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

CM Banks Q&A: Mangin on when community opposition would change BSA decisions

New York City Council · Sep 1, 2026 · starts 2:16:18 · 1 min 14 sec

Banks asks for an example where community opposition would cause BSA to reject or change an application advancing housing goals. Mangin notes BSA's site-specific approvals provide more latitude than rezonings to accommodate local input within legal constraints.

Chris Banks

Give me an example of circumstances where community opposition would cause BSA to reject or materially change an application.

Chris Banks

That otherwise advances the city's housing goals.

John Mangin

Thank you for the question, Council Member.

John Mangin

One thing I like about BSA is that they're all site-specific applications.

John Mangin

They're a particular project with a particular owner.

John Mangin

That contrasts with what DCP is typically doing, which is a, the City Planning Commission is typically doing, which is a rezoning.

John Mangin

A rezoning allows what it allows.

John Mangin

The city planning commission and council often are limited in how they can respond to community comments.

John Mangin

An R8A is an R8A.

John Mangin

You can't customize it in response to community comments.

John Mangin

If the BSA, it's a site-specific, owner-specific approval.

John Mangin

That provides more latitude, again, within the legal constraints that the BSA operates, to accommodate local input, community input.

John Mangin

And that's something that I would absolutely look forward to doing.

Chris Banks

Okay.