Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Public: George Janes opposes Mangin as temperamentally unsuited

New York City Council · Sep 1, 2026 · starts 4:00:16 · 2 min 5 sec

Janes, an urban planner testifying as a private citizen, describes his first interaction with Mangin as memorable for being different from typical government dialogue. He calls Mangin temperamentally ill-suited for government service, particularly land use, and plans to submit written testimony with examples of misleading statements during City of Yes.

Member of the Public - George Janes

Hi, I'm George Janes.

Member of the Public - George Janes

I'm an urban planner.

Member of the Public - George Janes

I'm not representing any client here today.

Member of the Public - George Janes

I'm here on my own time as a citizen.

Member of the Public - George Janes

My first interaction with Mr.

Member of the Public - George Janes

Mangin was about six or seven years ago.

Member of the Public - George Janes

And after it, I wrote my DCP contact at the time, quote, you shouldn't let John speak to people, unquote.

Member of the Public - George Janes

And clearly he's smart.

Member of the Public - George Janes

Clearly you've heard him speak.

Member of the Public - George Janes

He's well-spoken.

Member of the Public - George Janes

And that's not what I meant.

Member of the Public - George Janes

The interaction was memorable because it was so different from any that I've had with those in government.

Member of the Public - George Janes

While we might disagree, until then, my dialogue with people who serve, especially in planning, has always been one of mutual respect.

Member of the Public - George Janes

But from that very first interaction, it was clear to me that Mr.

Member of the Public - George Janes

Mangin operated differently.

Member of the Public - George Janes

As he showed during the City of Yes, he was there to win, to crush opposition, and to get a job done by any means necessary.

Member of the Public - George Janes

There are lots of places where this type of hard-charging behavior is appropriate, but

Member of the Public - George Janes

Government service is not one of them, especially not in land use.

Member of the Public - George Janes

In government, the process or how something is done is as important as what is being done.

Member of the Public - George Janes

And that's the issue, and that is why I am here today.

Member of the Public - George Janes

I believe Mr.

Member of the Public - George Janes

Mangin is temperamentally ill-suited to serving in government at any level, and certainly not in a leadership position.

Member of the Public - George Janes

I will be submitting written testimony with examples of Mr.

Member of the Public - George Janes

Mangin's misleading statements and half-truths made on the record during the City of Yes.

Member of the Public - George Janes

And which will be reflective of my own personal experiences, and I hope you use them as you see fit.

Member of the Public - George Janes

Thank you.