Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Agency Testimony

Commissioner Martin on remediation strategy and biocide risks

New York City Council · Sep 2, 2026 · starts 0:54:00 · 1 min 35 sec

Martin explains the aggressive strategy of ordering cleaning for all PCR-positive towers, and why blanket biocide was not recommended due to corrosion risks. He says the bacterial source was likely eliminated within a week of launching the investigation.

Commissioner Martin

That is a more aggressive strategy than our city has ever taken.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

Cooling tower cleaning and disinfecting effectively eliminates Legionella bacteria, but cleaning without testing first poses its own set of risks.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

That's why we did not recommend blanket biocide for every cooling tower in the investigation area.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

The frequent and aggressive

Commissioner Martin

abuse of biocide can corrode the internal cooling tower system and strip the protective materials, ultimately making way for more Legionella growth in the future.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

The CDC recommends a balance of strategic testing and remediation rather than blanket treatments.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

This summer, we struck that balance.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

The data indicates that any source of bacteria causing this cluster was likely eliminated within a week of launching the investigation.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

Over 90 people, 90% of the people in the cluster developed symptoms before July 7th.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

Remember, we called this cluster into order on July 2nd, just five days.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

After the health department launched its investigation, 90% of those who were sickened by this already had developed their symptoms.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

Symptoms typically appear two to ten days after exposure and can take up to two weeks.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

That means the majority of people who got sick were likely exposed in the week or two before we discovered the cluster.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

As soon as we learned about a possible cluster, we took action.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

While our team of epidemiologists, microbiologists, and water ecologists worked long hours to pinpoint and contain this cluster,

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.