Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Speaker Menin and Chair Schulman on dashboard not updating post-declaration

New York City Council · Sep 2, 2026 · starts 1:31:27 · 1 min 41 sec

Schulman raises that the Legionnaires dashboard was closed after the July 31 press release and couldn't be updated with four subsequent deaths. Martin says this follows the same approach used in previous clusters, and the website has since been updated with all 11 deaths.

Lynn C. Schulman

agencies, legionnaires, dashboards.

Lynn C. Schulman

literally say you cannot report any additional data.

Lynn C. Schulman

So once the department issued that press release, if you go to that dashboard, you cannot update it.

Lynn C. Schulman

So even though four additional people passed away since that press release, none of that information could be uploaded onto the dashboard.

Lynn C. Schulman

It just says the dashboard is

Lynn C. Schulman

sort of closed for business, like you can't edit it.

Commissioner Martin

And that's what we've done in previous clusters, Madam Speaker.

Commissioner Martin

We have a period of time that we do our investigation, our cluster, and when the exposure is over, we don't continue to update the public dashboard.

Commissioner Martin

This was not something that was new in this cluster.

Lynn C. Schulman

But for those family members that their loved one passed away, I mean, there are four people who lost their lives.

Lynn C. Schulman

And it just seems to me that it would be common sense that the dashboard, as additional people tragically lose their lives or additional people are perhaps hospitalized, that the health department would

Lynn C. Schulman

acknowledge that and update the dashboard accordingly so that the public writ large can get accurate information.

Commissioner Martin

Every single one of those lives lost is a tragedy for us, and we have acknowledged those lives.

Commissioner Martin

There were many, many public communications in which we did so, including in this testimony.

Commissioner Martin

The dashboard itself is one specific measure that we use.

Commissioner Martin

But according to our typical approach, we did what we've done in the past.

Commissioner Martin

with regard to the publication of the dashboard.

Lynn C. Schulman

Okay, I'm going to pass it over to Chair Shulman.

Lynn C. Schulman

Thank you.

Lynn C. Schulman

Thank you.