Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Speaker Menin questions lack of automated alert system for non-compliance

New York City Council · Sep 2, 2026 · starts 1:26:17 · 1 min 56 sec

Menin cites an NBC report that DOHMH has no alert system to trigger enforcement when owners miss reporting deadlines. Schiff explains the follow-up program for positive results but does not directly address automated flagging of missed deadlines.

Julie Menin

It was publicly reported by Melissa Rousseau of NBC that the department currently has no alert system to trigger quick enforcement when a building owner fails to comply with the new cooling tower rules, including the requirement under

Julie Menin

Chair Shulman's bill to report Legionella testing every 31 days.

Julie Menin

Is that accurate?

Julie Menin

And if so, why doesn't the city's portal automatically or through some type of manual follow-up flag miss five-day reporting deadlines or overdue 31-day testing requirements for immediate review and enforcement?

Commissioner Martin

Thank you for the question, Speaker.

Commissioner Martin

We do have a process by capturing whether or not someone is compliant with that 31-day sampling requirement.

Commissioner Martin

Let me hand it to Deputy Commissioner Karanja for more.

Corinne Schiff

Thank you, Commissioner.

Corinne Schiff

The local law requires reporting the level, the highest level

Corinne Schiff

of Legionella bacteria to the department, which is when we get to the point where we really want to be providing ongoing assistance to that cooling tower operator.

Corinne Schiff

So it is in the local law and also in our regulation that when Legionella bacteria, when the results from that sample and the council's innovation to increase the

Corinne Schiff

frequency of sampling to monthly is giving owners much more information.

Corinne Schiff

When they get that result back that shows that they have a level of bacteria where it's

Corinne Schiff

starting to show that they're no longer adequately controlling the bacteria growth in that cooling tower.

Corinne Schiff

They report that information to us, and we have a follow-up program to make sure that they are conducting the appropriate corrective action for that, that they are taking their compliance samples, that those compliance samples are showing that that remediation was

Corinne Schiff

effective, and if not, that they are continuing to remediate.