Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Hanif asks about Bronx DRIE enrollment decline analysis

New York City Council · Sep 18, 2026 · starts 2:10:23 · 2 min 45 sec

Hanif asks what analysis capacity DOF has to examine enrollment decline causes, particularly in the Bronx, and Shear provides detailed breakdown showing deaths accounted for 56% of the 1,203 decline, non-renewals 225, moves 250, and 23 transfers to SCRIE, noting DOF loses contact with those who leave.

Shahana Hanif

Is there, what kind of analysis capacity does DOF have to really look at what's causing an enrollment fall, particularly in the Bronx?

Jeffrey Shear

Yes, so we do have some more information regarding the Bronx.

Jeffrey Shear

I want to preface that by saying there are limits.

Jeffrey Shear

So when people leave the program, we lose touch with them.

Jeffrey Shear

They don't tell us why they are leaving the program.

Jeffrey Shear

But we have these figures regarding, let's see.

Jeffrey Shear

No, so this is regarding the decline of 1,200.

Jeffrey Shear

So I think the figures you are referring to is that re-enrollment peaked at 12,215 in 2019 and was 11,012 in 2024.

Jeffrey Shear

So we break it out this way.

Jeffrey Shear

That death was the largest reason for that decline, accounting for 669 of the 1,203.

Jeffrey Shear

That's 56%.

Jeffrey Shear

Non-renewals, 225.

Jeffrey Shear

So again, we don't know precisely the reason why people did not renew.

Jeffrey Shear

We're aware of 250 where tenants move residences, and we have 23 that transferred to the SCRI program.

Shahana Hanif

And then for the...

Shahana Hanif

The non-renewals,

Shahana Hanif

Is there reason not to check in?

Jeffrey Shear

Well, we do check in.

Jeffrey Shear

What mostly happens is we do not hear anything further.

Shahana Hanif

Got it.

Jeffrey Shear

We're very intent on making sure that people in the program who remain eligible renew.

Jeffrey Shear

It's very important for DOF that they renew.

Jeffrey Shear

We are proud of the fact that we have 95% retention rate, and we do that by sending many reminders.

Jeffrey Shear

Paper letters, emails, and also working with PEU with lists of people who have not yet responded.

Shahana Hanif

Understood.