Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Morano asks what additional safeguards DORIS needs to preserve communications

New York City Council · Sep 22, 2026 · starts 1:35:15 · 3 min 17 sec

Morano asks what additional safeguards DORIS would need to ensure substantive government communications are preserved; Smith-Cruz says council advocacy helps, encourages agencies to document exceptions, and notes RecordPoint only covers government-supported software while social media archiving is handled by a vendor.

Frank Morano

Thank you.

Frank Morano

Very briefly.

Frank Morano

Commissioner, your testimony describes record management policies, employee training, and technological systems.

Frank Morano

We also have a written policy telling employees not to use Signal, which we alluded to earlier, followed by an acknowledged incident involving disappearing messages.

Frank Morano

What additional safeguards, if any?

Frank Morano

Would Doris need to ensure substantive government communications are preserved, whether it's legislation, whether it's policy guidance?

Frank Morano

What else would you need?

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

Thank you for that question.

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

We definitely enjoy these points of advocacy.

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

that come up from city council.

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

It's very helpful to maintaining our request for agencies to communicate with their employees related to what they should be doing for their records.

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

So truly it's broadening understanding and ensuring that you two are

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

preserving your own records and submitting it to its proper channels.

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

I know that the City Council, for example, has its archives at the LaGuardia Archives, which we were able to visit and get a tour of, and they have a new director.

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

And we've talked to them about the Memorandum of Understanding related to City Council and Doris's archival records.

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

And so...

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

The best way we can support the work of archiving the city is to have a sense of how our own records are being archived and maintained and hopping on board to the records management platform that allows us to do this work.

Frank Morano

Would a requirement that agencies document exceptions and verify preservation settings address a gap in the current system, or can you already require that under existing authority?

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

Thank you for the question.

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

And just to clarify, a requirement to verify, can you repeat it?

Frank Morano

A requirement that agencies document exceptions and verify preservation settings in, say, a WhatsApp group, or I don't know how Signal works, but presumably there's something similar in Signal.

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

I see.

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

Thank you for that distinction.

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

As it relates to, thank you for the question as well, as it relates to the social media platforms, that is not what RecordPoint is capturing.

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

And so we set the parameters for the records management platform that we are supporting agencies to onboard into.

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

And that is for government-supported software.

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

As it relates to the social media, then, the vendor is the one setting up the ability to scrape those platforms.

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

And so it really is not, it's a very easy and foolproof method.

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

They just.

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

Connect their account and they're already being archived if they have a social media archive social account.

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

Unfortunately, as of now, there really is no way for us to capture what takes place in specific platforms because the technology just doesn't exist.

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

And so in some future moment, maybe it will exist and we'll continue to advance.

Member of the Public - Shanta Smith-Cruz

But as of now, the policy is set because of the limitation of technology as well as the likelihood that these messages are transitory and not really worth the government resources to retain in perpetuity the way that other materials eligible.