Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Schiffrin recommends disclosure, labeling, and training standards

New York City Council · Sep 22, 2026 · starts 2:17:44 · 3 min 21 sec

Schiffrin recommends clear disclosure of influencer relationships applying to paid and unpaid content, standardized visible hashtags like Spain's 'paid partnership,' regular publication of influencer lists, in-house training for employees and vendors, and an influencer hub modeled on the EU and FTC.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

And so a lot of what I'm seeing globally is disclosure and labeling of influencer content.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

And that has begun to attract the attention of regulators in the U.S.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

And overseas.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

I think that there's, given the amount of online violence and physical threats in the real world to journalists and influencers, I think that there's a fear of naming who the influencers are, for example, in the signal group.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

But I think we need to weigh that against the pollution of the information ecosystem and the mistrust created when audiences are not aware of the alliances or the agendas of the people that they encounter online.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

You know, I have great hope that New York could really be a standard setter for a lot of this.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

I think there's no reason we couldn't do sort of world first or standard setting in terms of research.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

I mean, in terms of regulation.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

So some of the recommendations I made, and I'm very open to revising them if it turns out we don't need them or we already have them, but I would argue for a clear disclosure of relationships with influencers, ideally applying to both paid and unpaid content.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

I think standardized disclosure, as just came up, and I was very glad to hear the Campaign Finance Board is thinking about that.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

So consistent use of hashtags, maybe at the top of the videos, remain throughout the video, be visible at all times.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

And it should be clear, again, what Spain has done of labeling things paid partnership as opposed to...

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

Collaboration and again some sort of label or disclosure for unpaid but persistent relationships.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

That should also be visible.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

I certainly think that some kind of regular publication of lists of influencers who work with the city agencies and explain what this consists of.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

As I mentioned, it seems to all go through marketing agencies that don't seem to provide information or answer questions.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

And another time I hope we can talk about city advertising because, again, Canada, Sweden, UK, there are many countries that have very strong guidelines on city advertising, and I would love us to maybe look at that as well.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

I also think that the mayor's office should probably publicize the disclosure rules far more completely

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

and provide in-house training for city employees, vendors, and marketing agencies that work with influencers, as well as training for influencers, agency staff, employees working with influencers, and vending and marketing firms.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

I think it's very important, especially for new hires.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

When you have a new administration, you may have people coming in who don't know the rules, so have to kind of make sure they're clear.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

Maybe the mayor's office could create a sort of influencer hub the same way the EU has done, and the FTC pages are actually very helpful.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

They provide clearly written information and ethical guidelines regarding content and information on regulations that cover influencers and best practices.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

And then I have this table of the U.S.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

Regulatory landscape and some of the European.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

Regulations as I mentioned I'm still working on this so I'm very open for

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

you know, more information.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

Very happy to, you know, bring experts together, convene, and keep discussing all of this.