Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Cabán presses DOC on criteria for 106 gender-aligned housing denials

New York City Council · Sep 23, 2026 · starts 0:56:10 · 2 min 10 sec

Cabán asks what specific criteria accounted for 106 denials out of 231 gender-aligned housing applications. Colon lists factors including stated gender identity, security concerns, mental health, and classification, but says she does not have a breakdown of gender-based violence findings.

Tiffany L. Cabán

Can you talk about the specific criteria that accounted for the 106 denials?

Tiffany L. Cabán

out of the 231 applications for gender-aligned housing?

Nell Colon

Yes, so when a placement decision is being made, there's a number of factors that are considered.

Nell Colon

One is the individual's stated gender identity, as well as their preferred placement, SCU, gender-aligned housing, et cetera.

Nell Colon

With that, there's also overriding security and management concerns that are factored in.

Tiffany L. Cabán

And I'm sorry, just to interrupt, because I have limited time.

Tiffany L. Cabán

What specific criteria accounted for the denials?

Tiffany L. Cabán

We're aware of what the factors are, but which factors accounted for the denials, 106 denials?

Nell Colon

Well, I think that that's what all of these factors are.

Nell Colon

Put in place on a case-by-case basis.

Nell Colon

So if we're talking about, let's say, the overriding security and management concerns, pre-screening information, mental health or medical concerns, classification, all of these things may be factors based on somebody's housing place.

Tiffany L. Cabán

So of the 106 denials then, how many involve a finding that the individual presented a current danger of committing gender-based violence, which is the standard recommended by the task force?

Nell Colon

Yes, I actually specifically don't have the gender-based violence indicator number for you, so I just want to be transparent.

Nell Colon

Can you get it?

Nell Colon

Yeah.

Nell Colon

Great.

Tiffany L. Cabán

That would be great.

Tiffany L. Cabán

And then if DOC relied on other grounds for denying the applications, other grounds outside of the current danger for committing gender-based violence,

Tiffany L. Cabán

I'm assuming you don't have a breakdown of what those grounds were.

Tiffany L. Cabán

Is that correct?

Nell Colon

No, not at all.

Nell Colon

In the context of what we have to give you today.

Tiffany L. Cabán

So I would also ask for those numbers.

Tiffany L. Cabán

I think it's really important to get a sense of, you know, what other factors are serving as the basis for denying placement of cisgender people in gender-aligned facilities.

Tiffany L. Cabán

I mean...

Tiffany L. Cabán

The DOC is essentially continuing to use criteria that's inconsistent with the task force's recommendations.

Tiffany L. Cabán

And obviously when you provide that information, you know, appropriately redacted, but we want to see it.

Tiffany L. Cabán

From there,