Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Garcia explains program closure protocols and revitalization

New York City Council · Sep 29, 2026 · starts 1:19:34 · 2 min 25 sec

Brenda Garcia says bilingual revitalization was created to prevent a revolving door of opening and closing programs. She says NYCPS has tight protocols before closure and has achieved net increases in bilingual programs.

Brenda Garcia

Yeah, you bring up a really, really important point.

Brenda Garcia

So one of the things, one of the reasons we called our efforts for over the past few years bilingual revitalization was because we needed to

Brenda Garcia

take stock of what existed, how they were being supported, and making sure that we didn't have like a revolving door of programs opening and closing.

Brenda Garcia

And so we invested in that.

Brenda Garcia

Programs close for various reasons.

Brenda Garcia

We have tight protocols in the K-12 space in which if a program is going to close, if a principal either says we don't have the certified teacher or our parents aren't interested or we don't have enough students.

Brenda Garcia

They complete a protocol that's then submitted to superintendent and L director for review and sign off.

Brenda Garcia

And ultimately, it comes to the Office of Multilingual Learners.

Brenda Garcia

We do everything to try to save a program before closing it.

Brenda Garcia

Like, really.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Do you have a sense of how many you've had to close?

Brenda Garcia

We have annual data.

Brenda Garcia

I don't have it right now, but we can get it for you.

Brenda Garcia

What I can say is that over the past few years, because of bilingual revitalization, we've been able to have net increases in programs.

Brenda Garcia

Because there was a time where we were opening up new programs, but programs were maybe closing as well.

Brenda Garcia

But now we're at a place where we're...

Brenda Garcia

having a net increase.

Brenda Garcia

So programs are being sustained, the existing ones, because we've been able to amp up the professional learning.

Brenda Garcia

We've been able to ensure that if a teacher resigns, retires, that we have a pipeline and we're connecting principals with the right resources to get the teacher.

Brenda Garcia

And at the Office of Multilingual Learners, we've been really

Brenda Garcia

ramping up our efforts to increase access to home language arts materials, which is really critical to be able to develop, to deliver high quality instructional instruction.

Brenda Garcia

And so now I can say that we're moving from

Brenda Garcia

bilingual revitalization efforts to boldly reimagining multilingual education because we're at a place where we are increasing programs and we have the mechanisms in place to really support schools and being able to sustain.