Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Gutiérrez asks if ECE definition will remain appropriate across ages

New York City Council · Sep 29, 2026 · starts 0:24:34 · 2 min

Gutiérrez asks whether the early childhood definition is appropriate long-term and whether framing changes for infants versus pre-K students. Branch says the family-informed approach will continue and applies across ages.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Wow.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Thank you.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Okay.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Excellent.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

And I know it's a little, it's obviously different for early childhood education, but what you shared seems simple.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

This seems a little more nuanced.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Is there any plan?

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Like, does this feel like the appropriate definition for early childhood?

Jennifer Gutiérrez

For the foreseeable future.

Georgette Branch

And I believe it is the most appropriate because,

Georgette Branch

All of our students are emergent learners, right?

Georgette Branch

They're emergent language learners.

Georgette Branch

Some of our students, they come in with very little language, right?

Georgette Branch

Initially, they're coming in as early as six months.

Georgette Branch

So we're really looking to the families to share information in terms of what they see as the best approach and utilize that to also honor that in the classroom.

Georgette Branch

So for the time and the foreseeable future, that will...

Georgette Branch

Continue to be how we define our emergent language learners in early childhood education.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Thank you.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

And does the framing of the question change for a six-month, like the parent of a six-month-old, two-year-old, three-year-old versus a pre-K student where

Jennifer Gutiérrez

maybe they have more language and you're asking more about the parent, you know, at six months or two-year-old versus the four-year-old?

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Does that framing change or is it?

Georgette Branch

It's consistent because at the, pretty much at home, whatever language

Georgette Branch

is introduced at home, whether it's the parent's language or maybe grandma comes over and speaks an additional language, we're really using that information to determine how to best support the child in the classroom.

Georgette Branch

So it may not even just be that it's a French-speaking household, but maybe, you know, there's grandparents or individuals who come over who speak Spanish as well.

Georgette Branch

And if the family shares that information with us and, you know, the hope and desire is that the language acquisition is advanced across all of those languages.

Georgette Branch

We support that.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Okay, excellent.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Thank you.