Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Gutierrez asks about AI Smart Select vendor and data privacy

New York City Council · Sep 30, 2026 · starts 0:41:39 · 3 min 3 sec

Gutierrez asks about the app's AI Smart Select tool, whether it was built in-house or by a vendor, and what personal data it captures. Morrisroe says it was built with an MWBE vendor, allows photo or text submissions, and falls under 311's privacy policy.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

And then my next question, and I'm sure the chair will...

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Kind of expand a little bit more, but I did I do have the app.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

I'm living in Bushwick a frequent trash service requester On the I noticed that there's like the AI smart select.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Sorry this chair is malfunctioning.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Um, I

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Can you share a little bit about, and I think it's helpful, I think it's been helpful because I think for a long time, especially if you're putting in a complaint about trash, there was a lot of miscommunication about what is illegal dumping, what is just a dirty sidewalk versus a dirty street.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Can you share if that feature or if the AI smart select tool, was that designed in-house or did you all contract with a vendor and whether or not

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Yeah, whether you use the vendor.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

And what information does this tool capture?

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Because I think while you're putting it in, obviously it's prompting you to put your address, your information.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

How much of that is the tool capturing and how much of your personal data is it holding on to?

Jennifer Gutiérrez

And is it a different data privacy agreement than the standard 311 app?

Joe Morrisroe

Thank you.

Joe Morrisroe

I appreciate the user feedback in that situation.

Joe Morrisroe

I take your kind of the different points in kind of an order, if I can, if I can remember it.

Joe Morrisroe

So first off, I'm glad you're using Smart Select.

Joe Morrisroe

I don't think it gives me a choice.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

I want to be honest.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

If you go to the app, I think it's at the top.

Joe Morrisroe

It's at the top, yes.

Joe Morrisroe

So a little bit of context behind that.

Joe Morrisroe

I feel like we have a tremendous CX team at 311, a customer experience team.

Joe Morrisroe

And this is one of the things where over time, they're constantly looking at what more do we need to do?

Joe Morrisroe

What else can we be doing?

Joe Morrisroe

So we know a lot of people come to the mobile app.

Joe Morrisroe

We've seen it grow over the years, obviously the growth of smartphones.

Joe Morrisroe

But people like to submit things in different ways.

Joe Morrisroe

So we were giving them one.

Joe Morrisroe

What the Smart Select does is give them another way and actually gives them three other ways, right?

Joe Morrisroe

So if you go to it, pull it up, you can take a picture.

Joe Morrisroe

You can use a picture.

Joe Morrisroe

You can upload a picture.

Joe Morrisroe

You can take a picture.

Joe Morrisroe

And now you can actually type in some text about a condition you're seeing, you're near, you can observe.

Joe Morrisroe

The smart select will then determine what it is.

Joe Morrisroe

You confirm and then you submit it.

Joe Morrisroe

So now you don't have to go through the step of having to fill out a form because it's doing it for you.

Joe Morrisroe

The work to do that was done by a combination of the OTI organization and its contracted MWBE vendor.

Joe Morrisroe

Do you know the name of the vendor?

Joe Morrisroe

I don't.

Joe Morrisroe

I know we call it an MWB vendor, so I don't know the name offhand.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Oh, that's the most generic.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Okay, we'll follow up.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

I'm sure I shall get that.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Okay.

Joe Morrisroe

And that went into effect last year.

Joe Morrisroe

The text was just an enhancement this year.

Joe Morrisroe

Okay.

Joe Morrisroe

But the picture version was last year.

Joe Morrisroe

And then very much falls under the same purview of privacy.

Joe Morrisroe

We are very serious about privacy at 311.

Joe Morrisroe

I personally believe it's what drives the public trust in 311 and has over 20 plus years.

Joe Morrisroe

That is very important to us.

Joe Morrisroe

So any tool that we use falls under that same purview with OTI and 311's privacy policy.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Okay.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Thank you.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Thank you, Chair.