Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Chair Ariola asks FDNY about response times in isolated communities

New York City Council · Sep 30, 2026 · starts 0:30:37 · 2 min 10 sec

Ariola acknowledges Council Member Paladino and NYU students, then asks how FDNY explains geographic disparities in response times in areas like Breezy Point and the Rockaway Peninsula. Sirocco says Rockaways response times are good, with the 4-7 Battalion ranking well, and describes six engines, three trucks, a bushfire unit, water rescue training, summer boat patrols, and must-fill units.

Joann Ariola

I just want to make note that Councilmember Palladino has joined us, and also we're joined by students from NYU.

Joann Ariola

We welcome you to the hearing, and we're glad that you're interested to come and view and see what goes on here.

Joann Ariola

You'll see council members coming and going from this hearing because there are other hearings going on that they are members of those committees as well.

Joann Ariola

So I just want to, and if you have any questions, happy to answer them after the hearing.

Joann Ariola

But I'm very glad that you're showing an interest.

Joann Ariola

Thank you so much.

Joann Ariola

Data from the city reflects geographic disparities in emergency response times, specifically in isolated communities, showing longer response times in areas such as Breezy Point and the Rockaway Peninsula.

Joann Ariola

My question is, how does the department, fire department, explain such dramatic changes in response times in certain areas?

Joann Ariola

neighborhoods as opposed to others?

Joann Ariola

And what is the department doing to address this issue?

John Sirocco

My data shows that in the Rockaways we respond pretty well.

John Sirocco

The 4-7 Battalion is the battalion that's in the Rockaways, and there's only five battalions out of the 49 that respond quicker.

John Sirocco

On the peninsula, we have six units and six engines and three trucks, including we do put in service at BFU.

John Sirocco

Which is a bushfire unit.

John Sirocco

Those units are all water rescue trained.

John Sirocco

We do in the summertime also put a summer boat program in play where we patrol the beach with that and also drones.

John Sirocco

In my view, we respond pretty well to the Rockaways.

John Sirocco

Those units are all must-fill units.

John Sirocco

So, for example, if somebody's out for training in the Rockaways, we replace them with another unit.

John Sirocco

So it's always covered because of its isolation.

John Sirocco

So I think we do overall on the fire ops side an excellent job of covering that peninsula.

John Sirocco

My data shows our response times are pretty good in the Rockaways.