Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Andrew Fine testifies on e-bike deaths and need for licensing

New York City Council · Sep 30, 2026 · starts 4:43:51 · 2 min 6 sec

Andrew Fine criticizes the long wait for public testimony, notes 17 e-bike rider deaths this year, and calls for licensing and registration to distinguish legal from illegal devices.

Member of the Public - Andrew Fine

Thank you, Chair.

Member of the Public - Andrew Fine

I just want to take a moment ahead of my testimony here to register the outrage that I actually found common ground with transportation alternatives today.

Member of the Public - Andrew Fine

We're all ticked off that it takes four and a half hours to get the public's input on this important legislation on street safety.

Member of the Public - Andrew Fine

Thank you very much.

Council Staff

Please keep it down.

Council Staff

Please keep it down.

Member of the Public - Andrew Fine

And I'd like to thank the three city council members who managed to actually stick around to listen to the public.

Member of the Public - Andrew Fine

I think it's outrageous that we don't have a full panel here when we've all survived half the day.

Member of the Public - Andrew Fine

I want to thank Speaker Menon for bringing attention to this important public safety issue and holding this historic hearing.

Member of the Public - Andrew Fine

The body count on our streets continues to rise unabated, and it must stop with this city council.

Member of the Public - Andrew Fine

This includes e-bike riders, 17 of which are dead this year so far, and that's an old count,

Member of the Public - Andrew Fine

pedestrians throughout New York City and Central Park, and city bike riders, including the heartbreaking death of a 15-year-old doubled up on a city bike on East 14th Street just this month.

Member of the Public - Andrew Fine

As a parent of three, two former teenage girls and one still teenage girl, this scares the living, you know what, out of me.

Member of the Public - Andrew Fine

I want to say that the bike lobby, which is heavily funded by Uber, DoorDash, Lyft, we see many of them today.

Member of the Public - Andrew Fine

They may wear T-shirts, they might be bearded, they might play the role of activists, but at the end of the day, I'd love you to ask them, are they paid for their appearance today?

Member of the Public - Andrew Fine

Are they drawing a salary?

Member of the Public - Andrew Fine

I can tell you one thing, that New York City E-Vehicle Safety Alliance is pure grassroots, all volunteer, and we love the city council to take this more seriously,

Member of the Public - Andrew Fine

pass licensing and registration, because as Janet just said, that's the way to actually tell legal from illegal.

Member of the Public - Andrew Fine

Thank you.

Shaun Abreu

Thank you for your testimony.

Shaun Abreu

Next.