Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Robert Polchinski testifies about being struck by an e-bike

New York City Council · Sep 30, 2026 · starts 4:45:57 · 2 min 16 sec

Robert Polchinski, 67, describes being struck by a fat-tired e-bike in Hudson River Park, suffering a broken arm, ribs, and leg, and says the offender was never held accountable.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

This is on, okay.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

Okay, thank you.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

I'd like to thank both Speaker Menon and of course the three chairs of the committees today.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

My name is Robert Polchinski.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

I'm a 67-year-old resident of 14th Street.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

Last December, I was struck by a large, fat-tired e-bike.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

Not one of those cute little ones you showed the pictures of before, but...

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

Much bigger.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

Over in Hudson River Park.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

I've been running and about to begin my trip home.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

Leaving the park, however, requires that you cross West Street, a major thoroughfare.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

As I approached the crosswalk at Horatio and West Street, the walk sign was illuminated in my favor, so I headed on my way.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

The only problem is getting there requires crossing a two-way bike path.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

Despite signs telling cyclists to yield to pedestrians at the location, the rider did not yield nor attempt to slow down.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

Instead, there was a collective, oh shit, as my right side and his front wheel collided.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

At the moment of impact, I felt like my heart stopped and I was a goner.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

If I had hit my head, there may have been one more obituary written.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

20 hours, first in an ER and later in a trauma center, revealed emergent injuries including a broken arm, three broken ribs, a broken leg, and internal bleeding.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

Recovery included surgery, months of therapy, and trauma for both me and my family.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

The e-bike operator in my case had stayed at the scene and I'm told was given a summons.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

I think for failing to...

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

although e-bikes are also not allowed in that park.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

I was able to obtain a copy of the police report from the precinct and the name and address of the offender.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

I attempted to serve the offender with a notice of claim, but the letter was returned undeliverable, no forwarding address.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

There ended any chance I had of recovering even a portion of the expenses incurred.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

Are you aware that current police reporting procedures do not differentiate between a pedal bike and an e-bike?

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

The machine that hit me was essentially an electric motorcycle, not a bicycle.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

We register and insure motorcycles and Teslas, but not e-bikes.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

This makes no sense.

Shaun Abreu

Thank you very much for your testimony.

Shaun Abreu

Remind me of your name for the record.

Member of the Public - Robert Polchinski

Robert Polchinski.

Shaun Abreu

Paul Polchinski.

Shaun Abreu

Thank you so much.

Shaun Abreu

And just a reminder to please state your name before you speak.

Shaun Abreu

Next.