Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Chair Abreu asks if dynamometers would make confiscation more equitable

New York City Council · Sep 30, 2026 · starts 1:56:21 · 1 min 43 sec

Abreu asks if a tool to objectively measure device legality would make confiscation more equitable, and NYPD says the idea is interesting but raises procurement and operational questions.

Shaun Abreu

So would a tool to objectively measure whether a device is legal make the mayor's confiscation proposal more equitable than reliance on visual inspection only?

Unidentified speaker

You're talking about the dynamo.

Shaun Abreu

I'm getting towards that.

Unidentified speaker

Okay, sure.

Unidentified speaker

No, so...

Unidentified speaker

When it comes to the dynamometer bill,

Unidentified speaker

You know, you are certainly right on the issue, right?

Unidentified speaker

And we think the idea of using this device is very interesting.

Unidentified speaker

It certainly speaks to the challenge that we have in terms of identifying street legal versus street illegal devices.

Unidentified speaker

So that's, I think, very important.

Unidentified speaker

Now, it is new to us.

Unidentified speaker

It is new.

Unidentified speaker

And we do have a lot, a lot of questions about how we would use it.

Unidentified speaker

It's new, I think, to any, it would be new to any major American city.

Unidentified speaker

And so that raises a host of questions in terms of procurement and cost and operationally, sort of operational functionality, right?

Unidentified speaker

How would this work in practice?

Unidentified speaker

How would we actually do it?

Unidentified speaker

And those are a lot of questions.

Shaun Abreu

And just so you know, I'm sure you know this already, the bill that I'm referring to only refers to the use of the technology.

Shaun Abreu

It does not speak to how it gets implemented.

Shaun Abreu

And so it gives the agency, your agency, a lot of discretion on how that gets implemented.

Unidentified speaker

100%.

Unidentified speaker

I do think it's important, right, before we are legislatively mandated to do this, that we first work and work with you and your team and the council to explore these questions and the answers to those questions.

Shaun Abreu

Will you join us for a demonstration of the use of the device?

Shaun Abreu

We're certainly open to do that.

Shaun Abreu

I'll invite you to that.